Thursday, September 25, 2008

Odd for Penang Division again expressing support for Abdullah - even before the AGM of the Divisions..

Only Ahmad Ismail was penalized not the rest of the UMNO leaders in Penang despite the fact that they were there with Ahmad Ismail ...

Some say the 2nd outburst after Abdullah Ahmad Badawi's visit with them was clear indication of a total disrespect of the President of UMNO..

Najib apologized BUT Ahmad Ismail and/or UMNO Penang never did not - such respect for the DPM..

The press conference was called by leaders and representatives of the 13 Umno divisions here led by state Umno liaison committee deputy chairman Datuk Abdul Rashid Abdullah and secretary Datuk Azhar Ibrahim.

Ahmad said Dr Koh should apologise not only to the Malays and Mus­lims but also to the Chinese in the country for creating so much tension.

“I want Koh and Gerakan to be responsible in case any untoward incidence takes place in our country.

“I hope we will not be pushed against the wall, ” he said, as supporters thumped tables and shouted “Hidup Melayu”. - Star, 9/9/2008 - Get out of BN, Bukit Bendera Umno head tells Gerakan


Now, we just saw that PENANG UMNO again come out even before divisional annual general meetings stating that all divisions will nominate the incumbents again... If I am an UMNO member, I would be very angry.. I would certainly reprimand this premature expression of support on behalf of the divisions. A reasonable UMNO member will say, we should discuss it at the general meeting first and come to a decision of the division - and then only express it...

Penang Umno's backing was given by its liaison committee deputy chief Datuk Seri Abdul Rashid Abdullah who said all the 13 divisions would also nominate Abdullah as party president and Najib as deputy president for the party polls later this year.

Rashid said the two men would be nominated at the forthcoming divisional annual general meeting next month.

"On behalf of the divisions, we have pledged our unwavering support for Abdullah and Najib to defend their positions. - New Straits Times, 23/9/2008 -Full backing from Penang, Kelantan

After all some months back, in July 2008, they already did express their support ...

Penang Umno has given its full backing to Umno president Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and his deputy Datuk Seri Najib Razak to defend the top two posts in the party.
State Umno deputy chief Datuk Seri Abdul Rashid Abdullah said that was the unanimous stand of all 13 divisions in Penang.

"We will nominate Abdullah and Najib to defend their positions as Umno president and deputy president respectively.

"They are a formidable combination and all the Umno divisions in Penang are united in giving our full support to them." - New Straits Times, 2008/07/06,Penang Umno solidly supports Abdullah, Najib

Was the reiteration of support because no action was taken against the others - only Ahmad Ismail?

But, frankly - this is all campaigning by the incumbents - nothing more. Who the Divisions decide to nominate will only be known after their general meetings?

It will be a good time for those attending the divisional annual general meetings - Hari Raya Cards, phone calls, meetings, promises ....mmm. They will be important until the their annual general meetings. After that....it will be back to normal..

Then attention will be shifted to the delegates...to the UMNO General Meeting...mmm

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

RM4.50 to feed detainee in lock-up is unreasonable - Thanks Teresa for highlighting this..

How much is allocated for a detainee's meal in a police lock-up? RM5-80 was already low - but today it is revealed that it is only RM4-50.

Thanks to MP Teresa Kok - this fact has been highlighted in the media - and now Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department T. Murugiah is doing something about this..

Our Anwar was not just in a police lock-up...but also in prison, and I am certain that there are so many reforms needed there - BUT alas Anwar Ibrahim is no Teresa Kok. He was free and that was that. He was not at all interested in bringing reforms - I have not heard him lobbying for improvements...

Congrats Teresa Kok for highlighting this...

Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department T. Murugiah said he wanted to first determine if it was true that only RM5.80 was allocated for each detainee’s meals per day.

“If it is true, then it is definitely not enough especially with the price of goods going up. A detainee needs to have breakfast, lunch and dinner.

“Breakfast would cost you at least RM2.50, while a good lunch would be a minimum RM3.50 and dinner RM3.50,” he told a press conference here on Sunday. - Star, 21/9/2008- RM5.80 a day not enough for meals, says Murugiah

But now, it is revealed that the allocation for food and drink for a detainee in a lock-up is only RM4-50...
A Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department was shocked to learn that only RM4.50 per day is allocated for food to each detainee in the lock-up.

T. Murugiah said this was ridiculous, especially with the increase in the price of rice, petrol and other items.

The RM4.50 covers breakfast (60 sen), lunch (RM2) and dinner (RM1.90).

Murugiah said the allocation should be raised so that detainees could get decent food.

“A normal human being living in the city spends at least RM10 on meals a day,” he said after visiting the Travers police station here yesterday.

He visited the police station following complaints by Seputeh MP Teresa Kok about the food she was served during her detention under the Internal Security Act (ISA).

“Detainees should be treated with respect and given proper food,” said Murugiah. - Star, 23/9/2008 -A mere RM4.50 a day for meals


It is good that the Deputy Minister is looking into this now BUT we expect government to be on top of things like this always..

Remember when Abdullah Ahmad Badawi caused the price of fuel in Malaysia rise - it did affect the cost of food, and now we need to look at increasing the allocation for food also in the prisons, detention camps, etc...

Monday, September 22, 2008

Immediate investigation whether PM influenced ACA investigation is needed..

I wonder whether an investigation has already commenced against Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, this Raymond Tan and the ACA officer concerned. I believe that what they did, if what Raymond Tan said is true, is something very wrong...

Or maybe, there will be no investigation -- because no one has filed a police report yet..

This kind of talk really makes me as a Malaysian very worried - I have serious doubts about the independence of the ACA, the Police, the Public Prosecutor...

The war of attrition continues over the sudden withdrawal of Sabah Progressive Party (Sapp) from Barisan Nasional last week as a “shocking revelation” came to light.
MCPX

raymond tanIts disgruntled ex-deputy president Raymond Tan (left) claimed on Saturday that he had been instrumental in preventing the arrest of party president Yong Teck Lee in June in relation to allegations of corruption.

abdullah ahmad badawi bn and yong teck lee and sappAn English-language daily in Sabah quoted Tan as saying that Abdullah Ahmad Badawi had wanted Yong arrested by the Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA). This was after Yong spearheaded a no-confidence vote against Abdullah’s leadership.

In defending himself against claims of ingratitude by failing to support the Sapp pullout, Tan revealed that he had intervened on Yong’s behalf in June.

He said he had pleaded with Abdullah not to arrest Yong as it would be a bad move, and had even gone on television with a plea to allow the latter to speak up. - Malaysiakini, 22/9/08 - 'I stopped PM from ordering Yong's arrest'
Are not all Malaysians equal before the law? When the PM can decide who gets investigated...and maybe even who gets charged...it shows us the sad state of affairs that the country is in.

I recall PI Balasubramaniam's 1st SD - where he made statements giving the picture that the police made sure that his statement did not have any reference to Mohd Najib Razak - similarly, the DPPs did not even ask questions about the DPM. Was this again on instructions of the PM?

Wondered why also the Altantuya case started so fast... Was that again on instructions of the PM?

I seriously wonder whether police, ACA, AG, Courts are truly independent - or are they still influenced by powerful persons....

Raymond Tan has clearly stated what he did - and there should be action taken against him, PM and whoever else...

In an immediate response, Sapp newly-appointed information chief Chong Pit Fah described this as a “a shocking revelation [...] that he can influence the prime minister to stop ACA action”.

chong pit fah“This is an admission by a BN deputy chief minister that the prime minister can interfere with ACA work,” Chong said in a statement issued yesterday.

He also wanted to know if the same influence could be used on other persons such as serving ministers, or similarly abused. - Malaysiakini, 22/9/08 - 'I stopped PM from ordering Yong's arrest'

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Malaysian Bar passes resolution on ISA at EGM(20/9/2008)

The Extraordinary General Meeting of the Malaysian Bar today(20/9/2008) unanimously passed the following Resolution

THE RESOLUTION

WHEREAS

THE MALAYSIAN BAR:

(a) Outraged that the Internal Security Act 1960 ('ISA') has recently been used to arrest Raja Petra Kamaruddin (a blogger), Tan Hoon Cheng (a journalist) and Teresa Kok (a member of Parliament);

(b) Deeply concerned that at present, there are more than 60 individuals detained under the ISA;

(c) Reiterating its earlier call, by its resolution of 15 March 2008, for the immediate and unconditional release of all persons presently detained without trial, including Manoharan a/l Malayalam, Uthayakumar a/l Ponnusamy, Kengadharan a/l Ramasamy, Ganabatirau a/l Veraman and Vasantha Kumar a/l Krishnan;

(d) Asserting the importance of upholding the Rule of Law, as enshrined in the Federal Constitution and the Rukunegara;

(e) Reaffirming the Bar's continued and unequivocal opposition to the ISA and all laws that allow for the detention of persons without trial, as they are unconstitutional, oppressive and undermine the Rule of Law;

(f) Taking note that, as a member of the United Nations Human Rights Council, the Government must fulfil the pledges it made, inter alia, to "promote and protect human rights and fundamental freedoms" and to promote "a free media, including in cyberspace"; and

(g) Deeply concerned that on 11 September 2008, the Government sent show-cause letters to three newspapers namely, Sin Chew Daily, The Sun and Suara Keadilan, regarding the reporting of certain issues.

NOW RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS, THAT:

1. The Malaysian Bar strongly condemns the arrests of Raja Petra Kamaruddin, Tan Hoon Cheng and Teresa Kok and strongly calls upon the Government to immediately and unconditionally release Raja Petra Kamaruddin, who is still being detained.

2. The Malaysian Bar strongly calls upon the Government to immediately and unconditionally release all persons presently detained without trial, including Manoharan a/l Malayalam, Uthayakumar a/l Ponnusamy, Kengadharan a/l Ramasamy, Ganabatirau a/l Veraman and Vasantha Kumar a/l Krishnan, who were ordered to be detained for two years from 13 December 2007.

3. The Malaysian Bar strongly calls upon the Government to immediately repeal the ISA and all other laws that allow for the detention of persons without trial such as the Emergency (Public Order and Prevention of Crime) Ordinance 1969 and Dangerous Drugs (Special Preventive Measures) Act 1985.

4. The Malaysian Bar strongly condemns the issuance of the three show-cause letters to Sin Chew Daily, The Sun and Suara Keadilan and strongly calls upon the Government to immediately withdraw the show-cause letters.

5. The Malaysian Bar calls upon the Government to uphold its pledges to the United Nations Human Rights Council to promote and protect human rights and fundamental freedoms and to promote a free media, including in cyberspace.

6. The Malaysian Bar calls upon the Government to demonstrate its commitment to, and to uphold, the Rule of Law as enshrined in the Federal Constitution and the Rukunegara.

Friday, September 19, 2008

Teresa Kok released - Will there be anyone left to be concerned for the others under ISA?

I am filled with joy that my good friend Teresa Kok has been released ... after about 1 week in Detention...

I am filled with joy when Sin Chew Daily journalist Tan Hoon Cheng was released after 18 hours....

I am concerned that Raja Petra Kamaruddin is still being detained under the ISA...

I am concerned about P. Uthayakumar, M. Manoharan, R Kenghadharan, V Ganabatirau and T Vasanthakumar, detained since 13/12/2007...

I am concerned about Shadul Islam, Abdul Sathar Mohammad Sarjoon, Faycal Mamdouh, Mahamad Nakhrakhel, Muhammad Shuaib Hazrat Bilal and Muhammad Zahid Haji Zahir Shah who arrived at the kamunting Detention Centre Taiping in July 2008.

I am concerned about Yazid Sufaat, a businessman from Kedah who was arrested in 9/12/2001 and is still there languishing in the Kamunting Detention Centre.. going to be SEVEN (7) YEARS soon

I am concerned about the many others currently being detained under the ISA and other laws that allow for Detention Without Trial...

I remember the words of
Reverend Martin Niemoeller..

FIRST THEY CAME FOR...


by Reverend Martin Niemoeller

In Germany, the Nazis first came for the communists,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a communist.

Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew.

Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Catholics,
but I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant.

Then they came for me,
and by that time there was no one left to speak for me.

Reverend Niemoeller, a German Lutheran pastor, was arrested by the Gestapo and sent to Dachau in 1938.Reverend Niemoeller was freed by the Allied Forces in 1945.

But, alas now a lot more Malaysians are getting more and more concerned and are doing things to bring about a better Malaysia...

And now, I am drafting another poem.....

In Malaysia, when Sin Chew Daily journalist Tan Hoon Cheng was released on 13/9/2008 after being detained for 18 hours, the journalist community, the MCA, GERAKAN,... left and were no more bothered about the others still detained under the ISA..

When the MP and State Exco member from DAP Teresa Kok was released on 19/9/2008, the _____________ left, and were no more bothered about the others still detained under the ISA..

When blogger Raja Petra Kamaruddin is released on ____, the bloggers left(?), the..... left, and were no more bothered about the others still detained under the ISA..

When P.Uthayakumar,M. Manoharan, R Kenghadharan, V Ganabatirau and T Vasanthakumar were released, the HINDRAF and Makkal Sakti groups left, the lawyers (?) left, the ______ left, and were no more bothered about the others still detained under the ISA..

And when all the ISA Detainees were released, everyone left and no one was bothered about the rest of those detained under the other laws that allow for detention without trial...

It is shocking that the ISA was used sometime in Jun/July 2008 - and we did not even know about it - and suddenly in July 2008, one
Shadul Islam and 5 others were taken to Kamunting Detention Centres. Why were they arrested and detained under the ISA? How long will they languich in detention - without even an opportunity to defend themselves with regard to whateever allegation that is being made against them which Syed Hamid Albar (Malaysian Home Minister) is satisfied warrants them to be detained under the ISA...

Go to ALIRAN's ISA Watch for more details of who and who are being detained under the ISA now (but alas, this is all we know - there may be others who are being detained under ISA and other Detention Without Trial Laws that we do not know about. Go to http://www.aliran.com/oldsite/monthly/2001/3e.htm

Do not sign online Petition to free RPK, Teresa Kok...unless you support ISA

There is an online Petition going around entitled "Petition to free RPK, Teresa & all ISA detainees" - Do not sign it if you are calling for the repeal of the ISA and all Detention Without Trial Laws, and for the release of all who are detained under these laws..

WHY? Because the petition also contains these words - that means you do not want the ISA repealed and that it is OK if it is used on certain people...

We wish to express our deep respect for the de facto Law Minister, Zaid Ibrahim, who has resigned in protest against the Government's use of the ISA on the three individuals. We agree with his view that "there [are] ample punitive laws to act against lawbreakers without having to invoke the ISA. [The law] should only be used on armed terrorists or those out to topple the government by force,"

The said petition sounds good and many will miss the fact that it advocates for the continued existence of the ISA...and usage of the ISA. Do read my earlier post entitled " Zaid Ibrahim's position on ISA must be opposed" [http://charleshector.blogspot.com/2008/09/zaid-ibrahims-position-on-isa-must-be.html]

For the curious one, the said DANGEROUS petition is as follows:-


To: Prime Minister of Malaysia



We, citizens and friends of Malaysia from the international community, call upon Dato' Seri Abdullah bin Haji Ahmad Badawi, Prime Minister of Malaysia, to act immediately to set free Raja Petra Kamaruddin and Teresa Kok who are presently being held in detention without the right of due process under the Internal Security Act (ISA). We also call for the release of the HINDRAF Five and others presently imprisoned under the ISA.

The two latest detainees - together with Tan Hoon Cheng, a newspaper reporter who was subsequently released following widespread local outrage and protests - were arrested on September 12th under the draconian ISA which permits the police to detain a person for a maximum of 60 days for investigations. Based on the outcome of the investigations, a person can be detained for two years without trial. The two-year term can be renewed indefinitely. The use of such legislation – a legacy of British colonial rule - violates the basic rights of detainees to due process and fair rule of law.

We are of the opinion that there is no basis whatsoever to justify the detention of these individuals, despite the manner in which some in the government-controlled mainstream media may have painted them as threats instead of objectively reporting the facts. Raja Petra Kamaruddin is alleged to be a threat to security, peace and public order as a result of posting in his widely followed blogsite – www.Malaysia-Today – various articles deemed as seditious and belittling Islam. In his defence, it should be noted that various Islamic political parties and organizations (including the Board of Directors, Muslim Professionals Forum in their Press Release on 13 September) as well as numerous Muslim leaders have publicly refuted the Government's view that the writings of Raja Petra are in any way a threat to the nation or to Islam; and they have called for his release. Further proof that this allegation is unfounded can also be found in the decision of the Malaysian Cabinet on 12 September ordering the authorities responsible for Internet policing in the country to unblock public access to Raja Petra's website. The website currently is still unblocked and the so-called seditious and anti-national contents are publicly accessible, although Raja Petra is in detention. Targeting an internet blogger who holds views that differ from the Government is unacceptable in any system of democracy.

Teresa Kok's arrest under the ISA has been justified by the authorities as stemming from her involvement in activities which can cause tension and conflict among races and religions. This allegation appears to be based on a claim by the former Selangor Menteri Besar, Dr. Khir Toyo, that she organized a petition presented to mosque officials to lower the volume of the azan (call to prayer). Teresa Kok has categorically denied organizing any such petition. Abdul Rahman Nasir, head of the Masjid Kinrara committee (the mosque in question) and Dr Siti Mariah, Member of Parliament for Kota Raja where the mosque is situated, have also denied that Teresa Kok was involved in any such happening. The unjustified arrest of a respected member of parliament and state assemblywoman is unacceptable.

We are encouraged that various leaders of the Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition parties have recently spoken out against the use of the ISA. We wish to express our deep respect for the de facto Law Minister, Zaid Ibrahim, who has resigned in protest against the Government's use of the ISA on the three individuals. We agree with his view that "there [are] ample punitive laws to act against lawbreakers without having to invoke the ISA. [The law] should only be used on armed terrorists or those out to topple the government by force,"

We urge the Prime Minister to take note that the continued detention of Raja Petra Kamaruddin and Teresa Kok will only strengthen the view of Malaysians and many friends of Malaysia around the world that the Government is rapidly losing control over the political situation and, as a result, is embarking on desperate authoritarian measures. These measures can only further undermine political stability and confidence in the legitimacy of BN rule. They will also undoubtedly contribute to the increasing capital flight and worsen the growing socio-economic turmoil.

The arrests of Teresa Kok and Raja Petra Kamaruddin and their detention under the ISA are not serving Malaysia’s national interests. Both detainees – as well as the HINDRAF Five and other political detainees - should be released immediately and unconditionally.

Sincerely,

Zaid Ibrahim's position on ISA must be opposed...

A lot of people have been praising Datuk Zaid Ibrahim...

He disagreed with the usage of the ISA to arrest Teresa Kok, Raja Petra and Tan - and for that reason he quit his Ministerial post - and that is great and praiseworthy. (Most members of the Cabinet would just sit by silently despite being opposed to the usage of the ISA - not even coming out publicly on their opposition, ...and certainly not tendering his resignation in protest....)

BUT be very careful because Datuk Zaid Ibrahim supports Detention Without Trial - he is OK with the ISA.

The Internal Security Act (ISA) should not be used against civilians, de facto law minister Datuk Zaid Ibrahim said.

The Act should only be used against terrorists or those trying to topple the Government by force, the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department said at a press conference at his home here on Sunday.

He was commenting on the arrests of three people -- Seputeh MP Teresa Kok, Malaysia Today editor Raja Petra Kama­rudin and Sin Chew Daily reporter Tan Hoon Cheng -- under the ISA.

...Zaid said it was time for the Federal Government to revert to the original spirit of the ISA, which was enacted to curb Communism and today should be used only on armed terrorists or those out to topple the Government by force.

“I am not calling for a repeal of the ISA, but it should only be use when there is a real threat to national security, such as armed terrorists, and not on civilians,” he said. - Star, 14/9/2008, Wrong use of ISA: De facto law minister (update 3)

Now, let us look at what the ISA can be used for .... and note that all it requires is for the Minister to be satisfied - and that Minister today is our Home Minister Syed Hamid Albar..
‘If the Minister is satisfied that the detention of any person is necessary with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of Malaysia or any part thereof or to the maintenance of essential services therein or to the economic life thereof, he may make an order (hereinafter referred to as a detention order) directing that that person be detained for any period not exceeding two years’. (s 8(1) Internal Security Act 1960)
And let it also be known that nowadays, we cannot anymore go to court to ask the court to review the decision of the Minister - to see if there is any real justification for the 'Minister's satisfaction' that resulted in the detention...

Recently, our PM, who said that ISA is good, talked about the possibility of ISA arrest....

The premier issued a warning that appear to indicate the possibility of an ISA arrest for the maverick politician at press conference at Putrajaya this afternoon to announce a reshuffle of cabinet portfolios.

abdullah ahmad badawi najib razak pc change portfolio 170908 06'He has become a threat to the economy and possibly (national) security," he said.

This in itself provides sufficient grounds for the authorities to invoke the tough security law, which provides detention without trial against Anwar.

And when asked what action the government would take against him, Abdullah refused to reveal his cards, saying: "I will not indicate what plan I will take, what I do will be in the best interests of the people and the country."

"Because of Anwar's actions, there are fund managers who have reported that Malaysia is purportedly no longer a good place for investment because of the unstable political climate."

Abdullah said the opposition leader has lied a lot about the country's economic status, even claiming that there is no Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) coming in. - Malaysiakini, 17/9/2008, Another round of ISA for Anwar?
Look at who is there in the detention centres - 'civilians' who the Minister is satisfied should be detained under the ISA..
-
Alleged member of "Darul Islam Sabah"
-
Alleged foreign agent
-
Alleged JI member
- HINDRAF - must be alleged something as well..

So, let us see what they can use for Anwar, the Pakatan Rakyat MPs, the others fighting for change...
-
acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of Malaysia (under the ISA)
- acting in any manner prejudicial to the economic life of Malaysia (under the ISA)

What if we want to use the Emergency Ordinance...
‘If the Minister is satisfied that with a view to preventing any person from acting in any manner prejudicial to public order it is necessary that that person should be detained, or that it is necessary for the suppression of violence or the prevention of crimes involving violence that that person should be detained, the Minister shall make an order (hereinafter referred to as a ‘detention order’) directing that that person be detained for a period not exceeding two years’. (s 4(1) Emergency (Public Order And Prevention of Crime) Ordinance 1969)

I hope you see how BROAD it is - and it is so open to abuse... and we cannot agree with Zaid Ibrahim who wants to keep the ISA - we have to say REPEAL all Detention Without Trials and release everyone now being detained under the Detention Without Trial Laws...

Recently, I came across an Online Petition addressed to the Prime Minister - I saw it in Charles Santiago's Blog [http://votecharles.wordpress.com/]---when you start reading it, it really looks OK --- BUT BEWARE because it also says keep the ISA....
"We agree with his view that “there [are] ample punitive laws to act against lawbreakers without having to invoke the ISA. [The law] should only be used on armed terrorists or those out to topple the government by force,”
I do not believe that Pakatan Rakyat Klang MP Charles Santiago would support or sign this petition once he had the time to read it completely - I know him, and he is a good man.

So, do me a favour warn everyone about this Petition - and tell them that by signing such a petition you are also saying OK to Detention Without Trial --- OK to the ISA....

The said Petition, which also supports ISA, starts off like this ....

Please sign the petition and forward to your friends.

To: Prime Minister of Malaysia

We, citizens and friends of Malaysia from the international community, call upon Dato’ Seri Abdullah bin Haji Ahmad Badawi, Prime Minister of Malaysia, to act immediately to set free Raja Petra Kamaruddin and Teresa Kok who are presently being held in detention without the right of due process under the Internal Security Act (ISA). We also call for the release of the HINDRAF Five and others presently imprisoned under the ISA.

The two latest detainees - together with Tan Hoon Cheng, a newspaper reporter who was subsequently released following widespread local outrage and protests...
DO NOT SIGN THIS PETITION UNLESS YOU SUPPORT THE ISA AND DETENTION WITHOUT TRIAL...

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Come out of the closet NOW all you who have no more confidence in the current PM and government

I have been thinking about these MPs that have lost their confidence in Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and the BN government, and have been wondering why they have not yet declared so publicly. Why have they not left the BN? Why are they waiting?

A friend said that it was because they wanted to be SURE...sure that there will be enough MPs crossing over so that Pakatan Rakyat will have the majority required to form the next government...(they want to move from present government --- to next new government - not just to find themselves as Opposition MPs...)

So, does that mean that if there is not enough to become majority - then they will still stay having 'confidence' (or should we say pretending to have confidence in...) in the premiership of Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and the present BN government?

Mmmm... interesting. If that is the case, I may have to say that it is rather unprincipled behaviour...

I wonder whether I would want such MPs in the Pakatan Rakyat?

I say, if you have no more confidence in the premiership of the Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, then publicly declare it....

If you have no more confidence in the BN government - then declare it.

If you are a political party - then follow the example of SAPP, and leave the BN. Decide later whether you want to join the Pakatan Rakyat coalition or not?

If you are a Member of Parliament, then leave the BN and maybe even your party - Be an independent like Ibrahim Ali or maybe join one of the other opposition parties...

Come out of the closet and openly declare your preference...

If you do, that will say a lot about your character...

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Let's focus on the Pakatan's 'kingdom' now - not just on expansion plans...

September 17 - We are still under the BN rule. There is no concrete evidence out there that there will be any changes of government in the near future...Anwar says he has the numbers BUT he would not reveal the names - for various reasons and concerns - repercussions.

Following what looks like a 'betrayal' ...a 'con'...' a deception'.., I looked for the response from DAP and PAS (the other 2 partners in Pakatan Rakyat), to this claim by Anwar and PKR that they have enough Members of Parliament to bring an end to the 51 year-old UMNO led-Barisan Nasional rule...

I also noted that PAS and DAP leaders were apparently NOT present at the last press conference of Anwar when he said that he had the numbers required, and this was strange. [I remember also how leaders of the various component parties of BN were apparently missing when Abdullah Ahmad Badawi made his acceptance speech after BN was victorious in the last Elections].

Even Anwar's statement is signed of not as Pakatan Rakyat - it would have been so much better if it was a Pakatan Rakyat statement - signed by all parties in Pakatan Rakyat. The delegation that ran after the BN MPs in Taiwan was looking very PKR only...

And, so when I browsed through the media today, it was good to see PAS and DAP speak about this transition of power, i.e. from the BN to Pakatan. (Sorry, we are not talking about that other 'transition of power' between current PM and his Deputy sometime in 2010)

PAS
Kelantan Menteri Besar Datuk Nik Aziz Nik Mat is still confident that Parti Keadilan Rakyat adviser Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim will succeed in his plan to form the Federal Government.

Nik Aziz said the Sept 16 date was just a "technical" point when told that Anwar had failed to honour his claim that he would be in charge on this date.

"His failure today is nothing... He did not lie to the people as he had tried his best but his efforts were curtailed by others," Nik Aziz said.

"I support the move to form a new government at the federal level. I will pray that Anwar's effort will succeed." - New Straits Times, 17/9/2008 - 'He will succeed in his plan'
DAP

In BUTTERWORTH, Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng said he believed in Anwar’s claim that more than 31 Barisan National MPs would cross over to Pakatan.

Lim, who is also DAP secretary-general, said it was just a matter of time before Pakatan took over the Federal Government. - Star, 17/9/2008 - PAS: Anwar will be able to take over the Government

Caution must be drawn to reports in many of these main-stream media, which are biased in favour of certain political parties.

If you watched the RTM and/or TV3 news, and looked at the behaviour and the script of the news - the bias is obvious. It is also not just a question of 'bias' - I believe it is also a willingness to be used by certain parties to propagate a certain perception (some call this 'spin'). Professional reporters should report the facts - pure and simple - especially during the "News" programme. Comments can come later during other programmes.

Let us see what these reporte tell us....

The 1st Report:- New Straits Times, 17/9/2008 - 'He will succeed in his plan'

Anwar failed today - but that he tried his best - but his efforts(maybe even achievements) have been curtailed by others.... - but at the end of the day, he will succeed.

[Anwar says he already has the requisite number - and the delay now is only because there is an effort to find the best way for the power transition. The list need to be kept secret to prevent undesired consequence/s to those on the list.]

The 2nd Report - - Star, 17/9/2008 - PAS: Anwar will be able to take over the Government

Here the indication that is given by the word 'believed in Anwar’s claim' gives us an indication that Guan Eng too has not seen this full list. He is only able to speak in terms of 'believe' or 'not believe'.

What becomes clear from both the reports is that both PAS and DAP, seems to support the move to 'form a new government at the federal level'.

There seems to be not so great a sence of urgency with regard to PAS and DAP - maybe this is because they have been at it for so long - this journey to erode BN dominance and ultimately form a new government.

Hence whether it comes next month or after the next elections or even later matters little - the important thing is that BN rule is ended.

PAS and DAP would also be very elated about their achievements after March - and would want to do all to ensure that changes are brought about fast - and that positition as government is stregthened. PAS have seen Trengganu fall just as fast...and know that a lot of work is needed fast, and that time flies and before you know it, the elections are here again.

I, too believe, that we must not be so bothered or pre-occupied as to when Pakatan Rakyat will be able to form the Federal Government - but we should focus on the bringing reforms and changes for the better in the 5 States that the Pakatan Rakyat rules, and in the constituencies that have chosen Pakatan Rakyat MPs and ADUNs.


That September 16 Statement (taken from Malaysiakini)

The following is the statement given by Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim at a 2pm press conference at the PKR headquarters in Petaling Jaya today.

MCPX

Today, Malaysians celebrate Malaysia Day - the day our country became whole and our people become united. This day has a new meaning. After years of struggle, after fighting against a system that is corrupt and unjust - we affirm that victory is finally at hand. Our vision of rebuilding this country and bringing its people together, as the founding fathers envisioned, is within reach.

anwar ibrahim pakatan rakyat september 16 annoucement pc 160908 02The economy is in turmoil with runaway inflation and joblessness creating widespread discontent. Racial tensions have been rising, exacerbated by the propaganda spread in the government owned mainstream media. The administration has offered no vision to steer the nation out of this quagmire and there is manifest erosion in confidence in the current government.

We in Pakatan Rakyat believe we can save Malaysia from economic ruin and the dangerous politics of racism. We will do so prudently, legally and in doing so we will not jeopardise the security and stability of the country and the safety of its people.

We have received firm commitments from members of parliament in excess of the number required to form a new government, and our government will reflect the diverse make-up of Malaysian society.

It has been our concern to ensure a peaceful transition of power. We do not wish to see a repeat of what transpired in the Selangor and Perak state governments, where following the victory of Pakatan Rakyat on March 8, documents were shredded and removed by the outgoing administration.

We furthermore advise radical elements within BN against the abuse of state power to unlawfully harass and detain our supporters.

The immediate investigation by the ACA (Anti-Corruption Agency) of Yong Teck Lee after the announcement by SAPP (Sabah Progressive Party) of its intention to move a motion of no-confidence against Abdullah Ahmad Badawi is another example of the tactics we reject.

The use of the ISA, as has happened to MP Teresa Kok, would be an unlawful impediment to the transition process.

In light these serious concerns, yesterday leaders of Pakatan Rakyat sent a letter to the prime minister at 2.30pm requesting a meeting to discuss the future course of the nation's leadership and to seek his assurance on the following important matters:

1) That the BN shall not hinder or prevent their BN MPs from acting in accordance with their conscience, constitutional rights and independent judgment;
2) That the BN government shall not invoke the Internal Security Act to detain any of the MPs who will join Pakatan Rakyat, or any of the present 82 Pakatan Rakyat MPs;
3) That the BN government shall not invoke emergency or police powers, or suspend the constitution, or dissolve parliament in response to our intention to form a new government;
4) That the Barisan Nasional government shall not impose roadblocks and impede the MPs from gaining access to the House of Parliament and the institutions of government.
We believe the prime minister will share Pakatan Rakyat's concerns for the welfare of the people and security of the nation. We are confident he will ensure the BN will act constitutionally and democratically to ensure that the transition will be peaceful, and there will be no actions taken to sabotage the wishes of the people or play on racial tensions in the country.

We appeal to all quarters in Malaysian society to understand our intentions are for the betterment of Malaysian society. The mainstream media, in particular, should accept the reality of these historic times and report fairly, accurately and without bias. The irresponsible tact that is used by the media to obfuscate issues, attack opposition supporters and instigate racial tensions must end immediately.

Following our meeting with the prime minister, we intend to proceed within the framework established by the federal constitution in the formation of a new government, with the assent of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong.

ANWAR IBRAHIM
Opposition Leader
De facto PKR leader


Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Kit Siang..Hadi...DAP, PAS - please confirm that it is TRUE..

Pakatan Rakyat is made up of 3 parties - PKR, DAP, PAS - and somehow, it would be good if Lim Kit Siang (or Karpal) and PAS leadership could also come out and confirm what Anwar has been saying - i.e. they already have more than 31 who will be moviong over to Pakatan Rakyat and that Pakatan Rakyat do have the required majority to end the 51 year ole reign of the BN.

Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim insisted he has in excess of 31 government defectors and call on Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi not to implement emergency rule during the takeover.

MCPX

At a packed press conference at 2pm today, he urged the ruling Barisan Nasional to commit to a peaceful handover of the government and not resort to emergency rule.

“We want a peaceful transition. We hope that Barisan will not put up emergency rule to stop MPs from going to Parliament or arrest (government) MPs or stop them from joining Pakatan Rakyat,” he said.

He has sought a meeting with Abdullah to show him the list of names of defectors and to discuss a smooth handover.

Anwar will need at least 31 defectors from BN and perhaps over 40 to form a stable Pakatan Rakyat government. - Malaysiakini, 16/9/2008 - Anwar: We've more than 31 defectors
* The word "defectors" have a negative connotation - maybe there may be a better neutral word that could be used.

Are those that withdraw their support from the current PM and the BN government, and shift it to the Pakatan Rakyat essentially for the good of the people in their constituencies and Malaysia generally doing something Bad? I do not think so - it is good and morally right unless they who move are doing so for some other ulterior motive -- i.e. for money, gifts, positions, etc..

The Star also carried a similar report:-
Opposition Leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has claimed that more than 31 Barisan MPs have agreed to cross over to Pakatan Rakyat.

He, however, refused to reveal the names of the 31 MPs.

Anwar told a press conference at the PKR headquarters in Petaling Jaya on Tuesday that he would give the list of the names to the Prime Minister, when he meets him.

The Permatang Pauh MP also claimed that the transition to the new Government has been delayed a few days pending the meeting with Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to ensure a smooth and peaceful transition.

He said it was up to Abdullah to agree to the meeting and its date.

Anwar said that in a letter submitted to Abdullah on Monday, Pakatan had made four demands to ensure a smooth transition:

1) That Barisan does not hinder or prevent the MPs from acting in accordance with their conscience, constitutional rights and independentjudgement;

2) That the Barisan government should not invoke the Internal Security Act to detain the MPs or any other current Pakatan MPs;

3) That the Barisan government does not invoke emergency laws or police powers or suspend the Constitution or dissolve Parliament; and

4) That the Barisan government shall not impose roadblocks or impede MPs from going to Parliament or any institution of government. - Star, 16/9/2008 - Anwar claims more than 31 MPs will cross over to Pakatan (updated)

But, alas it was always reported that it was Anwar who said this.

Has anyone seen any other report where it mentions that PAS and DAP are also saying the same things...

It would be good if the other 2 partners, i.e. PAS and DAP, in the Pakatan Rakyat coalition could also confirm that what Anwar is saying is true...

I must state that it will also be good that those who are going to move over come out now and publicly declare it to be the case... then 'No Turning Back...No Turning Back" - unless months down the road, Pakatan Rakyat is also not performing as promised...mmm