Saturday, January 15, 2011
Migrant Workers should not be charged 1st class rates at government hospitals in Malaysia
Sunday, July 25, 2010
Why some got citizenship? some PR status? and others still on 'social visit visa'? Was there discrimination when dealing with foreign spouses?
It is estimated that there are at least 100,000 foreign spouses in the country today. However, according to the Home Ministry, from 2001 to 2008, only 8,622 entry permits were issued to foreign spouses of Malaysians.
The largest groups of applicants were from Thailand (2,439), Indonesia (1,955), India (1,785), Singapore (864) and the Philippines (578). Vietnamese applicants were included in the “Others” category, which added up to 1,019.
Many are unaccounted for or in the process of applying for Permanent Residence status or Citizenship.
A total of 3,524 were awarded citizenship in the same period mentioned, out of which 253 were in the “Others” category but it is unspecified how many were Vietnamese. - Star, 25/7/2010, From Vietnam with love
Malaysia's intention of depriving developing nations of their best human resources is not right
PR Status: Categories Need Be Expanded, Minister's decision should be reviewable by court...
PR status to foreigners who marry Malaysians upon registration of marriage in Malaysia - Best Solution
Rights of foreeign spouses of MALAYSIANS being highlighted again
Are foreign spouses now being discriminated based on their nationality?
Maybe 100,000 foreign spouses - but only 8,600 given Entry Permits in last 7 years
Foreign spouses should get PR status on registration of marriage
Sunday, July 11, 2010
Malaysia's intention of depriving developing nations of their best human resources is not right
TANAH MERAH: The Higher Education Ministry’s proposal that excellent foreign students be given permanent resident (PR) status is to tap their ideas for the nation’s benefit.
Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Khaled Nordin said all quarters should view the proposal positively as many developed countries like the United States were practising it.
“Only students at PhD level will be accepted and they have to be researchers or lecturers with local universities.
“We want to share the knowledge to develop the nation,” he said after opening the Tanah Merah Umno Youth, Wanita Umno and Puteri Umno delegates meetings yesterday.
Khaled said it was still a proposal, adding that the Government would not freely give PR status to foreign students but only to those who qualified.
“We are not giving it to foreign workers but foreign students with high knowledge. Other countries are also chasing after them,” he said.
Khaled said he was also confident that the Opposition would not use it as an issue for the general election as they too agreed with the proposal. — Bernama - Star, 11/7/2010, PR proposal ‘to tap foreign excellence’
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
PR Status: Categories Need Be Expanded, Minister's decision should be reviewable by court...
Foreigners who wish to apply for a permanent resident (PR) status in Malaysia should acquire an entry permit first, the Dewan Rakyat was told.
Deputy Home Minister Datuk Wira Abu Seman Yusop said the matter was clearly stipulated under Section 10 of the Immigration Act 1959/63.
"Only those who had acquired the entry permit are eligible to apply for the PR status and enable them to get the red-coloured identity card or MyPR," he said in reply to Dr Fong Chan Onn (BN-Alor Gajah) during question time today.
Fong wanted to know the requirement and procedures for acquiring the PR status for foreigners and the latest statistics on the applications.
Abu Seman said only six categories of applicants would be considered in the issuance of the entry permit as set out in the Immigration (Prohibition of Entry) Order 1963.
"The six categories are persons in possession of specialist or professional qualification, persons in possession of a certificate from the home minister certifying that their admission would be in the economic interest of Malaysia.
"Wives and children under six years of age of persons falling within the above categories, wives of citizens of Malaysia who have not been living separately from the husbands for a continuous period of five years.
"Children of citizens of Malaysia under six years of age, and those who are allowed by the home minister on special compassionate grounds," he said.
25,000 PR applications in eight years
Abu Seman said the application for the entry permit could be submitted at any immigration office and the applicants must posses valid travel document or passport.
"However, the consideration and decision on the applications are the prerogative of the Immigration director-general.
"In the event that their application is rejected, they can file an appeal to the Home Minister within 30 days and the decision made by the minister is final," he said.
Between 2001 and 2009, a total of 24,883 applications for PR status were received and solved, he said.
"At present, there are 521 new applications being processed by the Immigration Department and the ministry," he added.
Monday, April 19, 2010
PR status to foreigners who marry Malaysians upon registration of marriage in Malaysia - Best Solution
“My one-year pass to remain in Malaysia expires at the end of next month. Since my husband has divorced me, I don’t know how to get it extended,” she said at her home at PD Utama near here.
Foreigners or ‘stateless’ people need their Malaysian spouses’ signatures to remain in the country. The pass needs to be renewed annually until they attain permanent resident status or citizenship. - Star, 19/4/2010, Mum needs identity to survive
PORT DICKSON: Yati Rahayu Abdullah, 30, is in a quandary since being divorced by her husband nine months ago.
The mother of two young children is deemed to be ‘stateless’ as she has no documentation to prove that she is a Malaysian.Stateless: Yati fears that she might lose Mohd Aiman (right) and Nuraryana if she is sent again to a detention centre.
Abandoned as a baby and raised at a longhouse in Keningau, Sabah by a Christian priest, she fears of being separated from her children and sent to a detention camp for illegal immigrants.
“My one-year pass to remain in Malaysia expires at the end of next month. Since my husband has divorced me, I don’t know how to get it extended,” she said at her home at PD Utama near here.
Foreigners or ‘stateless’ people need their Malaysian spouses’ signatures to remain in the country. The pass needs to be renewed annually until they attain permanent resident status or citizenship.
Yati, who never went to school, said she lived with the priest at his home until she was 13 and then followed him to Kuala Selangor.
Before they moved, the priest handed her a Malaysian identity card.
In Kuala Selangor, she worked at a Chinese restaurant and stayed at her employer’s home.
“I worked for the family without getting any pay for five years. I ran away when I could no longer take it,” she said, adding that she then started working at a factory.
It was then that she came to know her husband’s family who adopted her.
“However, when I went to the National Registration Department to renew my IC, I was arrested as they said my old one was fake. I was then sent to the detention centre for illegals in Pekan Nenas, Johor,” she said.
After six months, her adopted family sought her release by proposing marriage.
“I married my husband in March 2006 and we then moved to PD,” she said, adding that she then embraced Islam.
The couple were blessed with two children – Mohd Aiman Daniel who is now two, and Nuraryana Natasya, nine months.
Yati said her former husband has been giving her about RM100 a month for expenses since their divorce.
Yati said she approached the Welfare Department for aid but was told that since she was not a Malaysian, she was not entitled to any. - Star, 19/4/2010, Mum needs identity to survive
Remember the case of Romita Hasibuan...and her 4 Malaysian children... - Maruly Aziz Bin Abd Mutalib (14+ tahun), Sarah Nor Varah Hanim Binti Abd Mutalib (13+tahun), Yonatan Adam Fauzi Bin Abd Mutalib (11+tahun) dan Ismael Syah Putra (8+ tahun). STOP DISCRIMINATING SARAH,AND GIVE THIS MALAYSIAN CHILD HER MYKAD
Saturday, June 06, 2009
Rights of foreeign spouses of MALAYSIANS being highlighted again
Foreigners married to Malaysians should be treated equally as locals and be recognised as a part of our society, said Deputy Women, Family and Community Development Minister Datin Paduka Chew Mei Fun.“It is ridiculous for pregnant foreign wives to pay double the medical fees when they are giving birth to Malaysian children,” she said after attending a forum and workshop on foreign spouses in Malaysia, organised by Wanita MCA and the Institute of Strategic Analysis and Policy Research here yesterday.
She said the party and the Women’s Aid Organisation had received requests from foreign spouses to help them obtain citizenship and permanent resident status.
MCA Public Services and Complaints Department head Datuk Michael Chong said he had dealt with cases of foreigners who were forced to return to their home country because their Malaysian husbands wanted to divorce them.
He would be presenting some solutions to Home Minister Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Tun Hussein. - Star, 6/6/2009, Treat foreign wives equally, says Chew
See also older posts:-
Are foreign spouses now being discriminated based on their nationality?
Maybe 100,000 foreign spouses - but only 8,600 given Entry Permits in last 7 years
Foreign spouses should get PR status on registration of marriage
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Are foreign spouses now being discriminated based on their nationality?
I have stated that rightfully, when the marriage is registered in Malaysia should be given a PR Status, as of right.
There really is no justification for the present practice of now giving until they have had their 1-year visas for 5 years, and this means that only after 6 years will they get their PR status.
Concern should be for children of the marriage and the parents/dependents of the Malaysian spouse, if the Malaysian spouse prematurely dies. At present, with a visa applied for by the Malaysian husband, it will mean that the foreign spouse will have to leave Malaysia and go back to her home country. What happens to the children? What happens to the other obligations and responsibilities of the surviving spouse? It certainly will cause injustice and unacceptable problems...
Now, we hear of the possibility that there may be discrimination practiced by the Immigration authorities and the government of Malaysia depending on nationality of the foreign spouse..
Remember, our constitution guarantees equality ...
See also earlier posts:-Maybe 100,000 foreign spouses - but only 8,600 given Entry Permits in last 7 years,Chinese women who have settled down in Malaysia with their Malaysian spouses face a host of problems, chief among them the difficulty in applying for permanent resident status.According to reports in the Chinese press today, 10 of them voiced what they claimed was unfair treatment by the immigration department, at a press conference called by Federal Territory MCA Public Service and Complaint Bureau chief Dr Jeffrey Goh Sim Ik in Kuala Lumpur on Saturday.
Most of them have their marriage registered in Malaysia and their marriages are also recognised by the Chinese embassy.
But despite having stayed for more than five years in the country, these Chinese spouses are unable to get permanent resident status, hence being denied of the opportunity to work.
They claimed they had problem even getting the application form from the less-than-friendly officers at the department.
"When the immigration officers learnt that we are Chinese nationals they refuse to sell us the application form, telling us that there are no rules that say Chinese nationals can apply for permanent resident status.
"Those who managed to get the form and submitted their applications do not get any reply from the department," some of the Chinese spouses lamented.
They also complained of discrimination by the immigration as they have to pay RM600 annually to get their visas renewed while their counterparts from other countries need only pay RM90.
"Furthermore, we have to renew our visas every year while those from other countries need only do it every two or three years or even five years; It is unfair."
Goh said he will check with the immigration to see if there are unwritten rules against granting PR to Chinese nationals.
He said as far as he knew, Chinese wives of Malaysians who have ed in the country for five years can apply for the "permit masuk" (entry permit) which will allows them to apply for PR status.
"There are no written rules to say Chinese wives cannot apply to become permanent residents".
Meanwhile, Immigration director-general Datuk Wahid Md Don denied the department has been rejecting the PR applications by Chinese wives.
He also said there are no rules to bar any national from applying to become a permanent resident in Malaysia.
Asked by Oriental Daily to comment on the complaints by the Chinese spouses, Wahid said there must have been some misunderstanding. He welcomed complainants to see him. - Sun, 10/5/2009, Immigration woes of Chinese wives
Foreign spouses should get PR status on registration of marriage
Thursday, March 12, 2009
Maybe 100,000 foreign spouses - but only 8,600 given Entry Permits in last 7 years
MORE than 8,600 foreigners, who are the spouses and children of Malaysians, have been given entry permits to stay in the country. Home Minister Datuk Seri Syed Hamid Albar said 2,439 of them were Thais. The second largest group of 1,955 were Indonesians, followed by Indians, 1,785, Singaporeans, 846, Filipinos, 578 and other nationalities, 1,019. These permits were issued from 2001 to last year. Syed Hamid was replying to a question by Tan Ah Eng (BN-Gelang Patah). - New Straits Times, 12/3/2009, Entry permits for foreign spouses
As soon as the marriages are registered in Malaysia, foreign spouses of Malaysians should immediately be given Entry Permits, which would give them permanent residence status.
In the event, that there is an unexpected death of the Malaysian spouse (before the foreign spouse has been here more than 5 years and have had obtained her Entry Permit), the current situation in Malaysia will not allow the foreign spouse to continue to remain here in Malaysia and look after children of her marriage (who will be all Malaysians) and/or the parents/relatives/dependents of her now deceased Malaysian spouse. And this is definitely not right.
The foreign spouse then may have to uproot her Malaysian children - and go back to their country of origin. Is this right? But, the problem is that even if the foreign parent wishes to stay in Malaysia, with the children, it is generally not possible...considering her ability to remain in Malaysia depended on her Malaysian spouse being alive.
The foreign spouse then may have to leave the elderly parents/dependents of her now deceased Malaysian spouse and leave the country...
The foreign spouse may also have to leave the matrimonial home in Malaysia and go back...
And, that is why there must be a change in the law, and Entry Permits must be issued to the foreign spouse on the point of registration of a marriage. (Of course, Entry Permits could always be revoked later - if there is fraud, etc...)
| Entry Permit (EP) is a permit issued to foreigners who are not citizen of Malaysia entering to reside in this country. Those who have been issued with EP are exempted from applying for any type of Pass either for employment or other purpose. | ||||||||||
| ||||||||||
As a lure, the government is giving their foreign spouses and children Entry Permits within 6 months from the date of application. Sometimes, these applications can also be made before the actual return.
For Malaysians who have been living(working, etc...) in this country all the while, their foreign spouses will only get their Entry Permits after more than 5 years have lapsed. No time is also specified as to when they will get the Entry Permit after submission of their applications.
This Discrimination must end...
This is an issue concerning children...and it must be a priority
This is an issue concerning the elderly...and it must be a priority
This is an issue concerning family ...and Asian values...and it must be a priority.
Read also my earlier posting/s on this matter:- Foreign spouses should get PR status on registration of marriage