NOT OPEN? - so, will it be yet another 'secret' proceedings, where I believe the number of government MPs is more than the Opposition. (Some say otherwise, it can be open to public...Anyway just AMEND these standing orders to ensure greater transparency and openness...)
What about LIVE TELECAST just like Parliamentary Sessions over TV and Internet?
Remember that all MPs are 'wakil rakyat/peoples' representative', and as such they are DUTY BOUND to keep the constituents informed.
Parliamentary Special Select Committee for Agencies under the Prime Minister's Department- do we even TRUST them - and are they even competent to look into this issue. We have seen our MPs in action, and we wonder about the competency of most - and their capacity to be independent as most have NO personal opinion/views and are merely 'YES MAN' to their party bosses.
If the select committee session was broadcasted LIVE or open to the public - this may be apparent.
AZAM BAKI's hiding of share ownership/trading of his brothers by allowing brother and others to use his share trading account - CLEARLY AN OFFENCE
AZAM BAKI's non-disclosure of acquisition of shares - clearly a MISCONDUCT under PUBLIC OFFICERS (CONDUCT AND DISCIPLINE) REGULATIONS 1993PU(A) 395/1993
Prime Minister and Chief Secretary selection procedure that failed to discover many of these - clearly failure/incompetence of the entire selection process...
Why is the relevant law enforcement so slow in taking action? Why no arrest, investigation and prosecution.
Is there any need this Select Committee to discuss the share ownership of Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) Tan Sri Azam Baki- it has to look into the MORE SERIOUS issues...
The failure the existing CHECK and Balance Mechanisms -
# Borhan Dolah(Chairman) and MACC’s Consultation and Corruption Prevention Panel
# Tan Sri Abu Zahar bin Dato’ Nika Ujang, chairman of the MACC’s Anti-Corruption Advisory Board
I hope the Select Committee recommend the sacking Borhan Dolah and Tan Sri Abu Zahar, and recommend more democratic persons to be Chairman.
The SELECT COMMITTEE hopefully will recommend that the Prime Minister/Government REJECT THE RESIGNATION OF TERENCE GOMEZ - a person like him is suitable as Chairpersons ..
WHO WILL THE SELECT COMMITTEE BE HEARING? Terence Gomez, journalist Lalitha Kunaratnam...
Lalitha Kunaratnam - Embattled MACC chief commissioner Tan Sri Azam Baki has filed a defamation suit against anti-graft activist Lalitha Kunaratnam.The suit was filed at the Kuala Lumpur High Court through legal firm Messrs Zain Megat & Murad on behalf of Azam on Wednesday (Jan 12).
Will the Select Committee urge Azam Baki to withdraw suit against investigative journalist Lalitha..
See earlier related posts:-
Azam Baki (innocent until proven guilty) but suitability to remain MACC chief??? Terence (MACC Panel member) 'quits'
Malaysian Anti-Corruption 'problems', 5 check and blance mechanisms, silence of the Parliamentarians' Special Committee on Corruption?
Hiding identity using others' share trading account, bank account? The Azam Baki case raises concerns
PUBLIC OFFICERS (CONDUCT AND DISCIPLINE) REGULATIONS 1993PU(A) 395/1993 - Where is report of actions, offenders and punishment?
Parliament Select Committee proceeding on Azam Baki would not be open to public, says Art Harun
- Nation
-
Sunday, 16 Jan 2022
PETALING JAYA: All Parliament Select Committee proceedings, including the upcoming Wednesday (Jan 19) meeting to discuss the share ownership of Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) Tan Sri Azam Baki will not be open to the public due to Parliamentary standing orders, says Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun.
The Dewan Rakyat Speaker said that all proceedings of the Special Select Committee and other committees are subject to the provisions of standing orders.
"Standing orders don't allow open proceedings.
"In fact, standing order disallows discussion or even disclosure of witnesses, witness statements and contents of the proceedings until a report has been presented to the Dewan," he told The Star on Sunday (Jan 16).
Azhar said that this would preserve the integrity of such proceedings.
"This is also to ensure complete cooperation from everyone involved," said Azhar.
Dr Edmund Terence Gomez, who resigned from the MACC’s Consultation and Corruption Prevention Panel last month, had urged the Wednesday proceeding of the Parliamentary Special Select Committee for Agencies under the Prime Minister's Department to be open to the public and media.
Gomez stressed that it was important to ensure that there was no attempt to cover up.
"While it's good to have the PSC, I would also like to argue that the PSC must be open to the media and the public. It is important that the medialy is also privy to the discussions in PSC," he said.
Azam is expected to be questioned by the Parliamentary Select Committee (PSC) for Agencies under the Prime Minister’s Department on his involvement in the share trading controversy next week.
According to PSC committee member and Kota Kinabalu MP Chan Foong Hin, Azam has been notified and is to appear before the nine-member committee on Jan 19.
The meeting will be held at 2pm in Parliament.
As part of the eight new select committees, the select committee for agencies was announced in August 2018 by former speaker Tan Sri Mohamad Ariff Md Yusof in order to monitor key government ministries and issues.
Select committees have the prerogative to summon witnesses.
Previously held hearings scrutinise how Putrajaya spent taxpayers’ money. - Star, 16/1/2022
- Nation
-
Wednesday, 12 Jan 2022
PUTRAJAYA: Embattled MACC chief commissioner Tan Sri Azam Baki has filed a defamation suit against anti-graft activist Lalitha Kunaratnam.
The suit was filed at the Kuala Lumpur High Court through legal firm Messrs Zain Megat & Murad on behalf of Azam on Wednesday (Jan 12).
The firm said the suit was in relation to the articles published and republished by Lalitha in the Independent News Services on Oct 25 and Dec 15 last year.
“Instead of responding to our client’s Letter of Demand issued on Jan 6, she (Lalitha) has through her lawyer issued a press statement published on her Twitter account, where in she claimed to stand by her publication and republication, the contents of which our client strenuously maintains are defamatory.
“Our client is therefore constrained to file this suit before the expiry of 14 days from the date of the Letter of Demand to protect his good name, reputation and professional standing,” it said in a statement.
The writ of summons, as well as the statement of claim filed by Azam, was sighted by The Star.
The firm said Azam was merely asserting his rights as enshrined by the Federal Constitution and applicable laws, to seek the necessary and appropriate reliefs from the Malaysian courts.
“Our client strongly believes that this will also provide the defendant a similar right and an opportunity to justify her claims in court and not merely engage in a trial by the media,” it said.
The firm said Azam will not be making further statements in relation to the matter.
“He has full confidence in the Malaysian courts to hear and decide on this matter accordingly.
“Our client wishes to make clear his unwavering commitment that the MACC will always protect all whistleblowers who fall within the ambit of the Whistleblower Protection Act,” it said. - Star, 12/1/2022
Business Ties Among MACC Leadership: How Deep Does It Go? (Part 1)
By Lalitha Kunaratnam
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia--Of late, there has been a steady stream of negative headlines involving the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC), leaving many wondering how long the embattled Chief Commissioner will hold on to his job.
A blog, “Edisi Siasat”, has been making outrageous claims that the powers entrusted to law enforcement officers have been manipulated for private gain. One of the top officers implicated in the widening scandal is the Chief Commissioner himself – Azam Baki, claiming that he is linked to several companies.
Azam began his career at the Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA) in 1984 as an Assistant Investigation Officer. From then on, he quickly rose to the top echelons of power: Director of Intelligence in 2013; Director of Investigation in 2015; Deputy Chief Commissioner (Operations) in 2016; and Chief Commissioner in 2020.
As he was rising to the top, Azam’s brothers became increasingly involved in numerous businesses. The complex details of business ownership and control reveal an interesting development – the nexus between business and law enforcement.
Azam Baki
Azam was a shareholder in Gets Global Berhad (formally known as KBES Berhad). He held 1,930,000 shares as at 30 April 2015 and 1,029,500 shares as at 31 March 2016. In addition, he was a warrant holder in Excel Force MSC Berhad. He held 2,156,000 warrants back in March 2016.
All these investments were only made for a very short period of time. It is uncertain if Azam has declared his shares and warrants acquired during his position as a Director of Investigation.
According to Section 10 of the Public Officers Regulation (Conduct and Discipline) 1993, all public servants must declare both movable properties, such as money in bank accounts, motor vehicles, jewelleries, firearms, shares, warrants, stocks, bonds and securities, as well as immovable properties, such as land, landed properties, and of course, business ownership or directorship.
In addition, there are related rules in Service Circular Number 3/2002 – Ownership and Declaration of Assets by Public Officials, which prevents a public servant from owning more than RM100,000 worth of shares in any company.
If Azam had failed to declare his shares and warrants in these publicly listed companies, this would be a serious offence and he could be subjected to disciplinary action.
Nasir Baki
Nasir Baki, Azam’s brother, is also a former shareholder in Gets Global Berhad. He held 3,728,000 shares as at 31 March 2016.
Based on publicly available reports from the Companies Commission of Malaysia (CCM) and Credit Tip-Off Service (CTOS), Nasir is currently a director of nine companies: Integriti Padu Sdn Bhd which specialises in trading IT products and services; Ipadu Holdings Sdn Bhd which specialises in reselling of computer hardwares and softwares; AAKH Development Sdn Bhd which is a property developer; Ipadu Mining Sdn Bhd which specialises in mining; Header Management Solutions Sdn Bhd which is involved in wholesale; Panji Positif (M) Sdn Bhd which is involved in general trading; Koolit Dot MY Sdn Bhd which is involved in the export and import of biotech pharmaceuticals; and Idealyst SA Sdn Bhd which is involved in beauty treatments.
Apart from being a shareholder (in addition to being director) for most of the above companies, Nasir is also a shareholder for RI Intelligence Sdn Bhd which is a private investigation and detective company. Another notable shareholder for this company is Mohamad Hazmi Abu Kassim, the son of former MACC Chief Commissioner Tan Sri Abu Kassim.
Tan Sri Abu Kassim
Abu Kassim was appointed as an Investigation Officer at the ACA in 1984, the same year as Azam. There, he held various positions until his appointment as Deputy Director General in charge of operations at ACA Malaysia, and subsequently as Chief Commissioner of the MACC in January 2010. He held the position of Chief Commissioner for more than six years until July 2016.
His last posting during retirement was as the Director General of the National Center for Governance, Integrity and Anti-Corruption (GIACC).
Abu Kassim is presently a director of four companies: the 1Malaysia Development Bhd, Prasarana Malaysia Bhd, Alam Flora Sdn Bhd and Yayasan Rangkaian Sahabat.
Mohamad Hazmi Abu Kassim
Hazmi is currently a director for ten companies: Manja Abadi Sdn Bhd which is involved in property investment; J&H Consultancy Sdn Bhd which specialises in financial consultancy services; Passive Massive Sdn Bhd which is involved in franchising retails stores; Uji Niaga Sdn Bhd which is a driving academy; Cube Network Sdn Bhd which is involved in consultancy; SMGB Minerals Sdn bhd which specialises in mining of ores; Corvo Network Sdn Bhd which specialises in telecommunications activities, Prolific Group Sdn Bhd which is involved in investment holding; Alpha Orange Sdn Bhd which specialises in civil engineering works for telecommunication towers; and RI Intelligence Sdn Bhd which is a private investigation and detective company.
Hazmi is also a former director for four companies: Premium Hill Marketing Sdn Bhd which is involved in general trading; Uji Niaga Agro Sdn Bhd which is involved in agriculture; Akademi Propandu Sdn Bhd which is a driving academy and Kehongbao Sdn Bhd which is involved in retail of food and beverages.
Apart from being a director and shareholder for most of the above companies, Hazmi is also a business owner for Osiris Consultancy which specialises in management services.
Hazmi’s high involvement in such a variety of businesses from the tender age of 22 is intriguing. Together, Azam’s brothers and Abu Kassim’s son, hold a conglomerate, as shown below:-
RI Intelligence Sdn Bhd is a private limited company incorporated in November 2006. Currently, the shareholders include Hazmi and Nasir. Hazmi was also appointed as a director in September 2016, ie. two months after Abu Kassim left MACC.
Although the company’s website was recently discontinued after the negative headlines about the MACC, it conducts background checks on job applicants, employees, and companies on behalf of its clients. It even claims to offer a more extensive background check on certain individuals slated for high-profile or high-risk positions.
Generally, these types of companies have three broad functions: collection, analysis as well as covert action. Collection and analysis are straightforward and through various means. Information on local and foreign persons, public officials, politicians, places, events, and activities are collected and analysed. This may include information not easily obtained through publicly available sources or diplomatic contacts. The manner of RI Intelligence’s data collection and analysis is unknown.
Covert actions are used to influence political, military, or economic conditions or situations abroad, where it is intended that the role of the government will not be apparent or acknowledged publicly. These might consist of propaganda activities, support to political or military factions within a particular country, or actions undertaken to disrupt or support illicit activities such as firearms smuggling and narcotics trafficking. Due to lack of publicly available information on RI Intelligence, the true nature of its activities is unknown.
To be continued in Part 2
*Lalitha Kunaratnam is an investigative journalist and a consultant researcher for an anti-corruption agency. She is writing in her own capacity, and the views expressed are not necessarily those of INS*
Business Ties Among MACC Leadership: How Deep Does It Go? (Part 2)
By Lalitha Kunaratnam
A blog, “Edisi Siasat”, continues to
make claims that the powers entrusted to law enforcement officers have
been manipulated for private gain.
One of the top officers
implicated in the widening scandal is the Chief Commissioner himself -
Azam Baki, with claims raised that his proxy is Dato Sri’ Lim Kok Han.
Lim Kok Han
Kok
Han was a shareholder in Gets Global Berhad (formally known as KBES
Berhad). He held 2,322,200 shares as at 30 April 2015 and 2,671,200
shares as at 31 March 2016. In addition, he was a warrant holder in
Excel Force MSC Berhad. He held 328,000 warrants back in March 2016.
These shares and warrants were held during the same period as Azam.
Based
on publicly available reports from the Companies Commission of Malaysia
(CCM) and Credit Tip-Off Service (CTOS), Kok Han is currently a
director of six companies: Edisi Firma Sdn Bhd which is involved in
investment holding; Agensi Pekerjaan Komms Sdn Bhd which is job agency;
Definex Sdn Bhd which is involved in investment holding; Titanium Stream
Sdn Bhd which is involved in selling and distributing wine and liquor;
Prismavest Sdn Bhd which is now dormant and Andy Noodles House and
Bistro which is a family restaurant.
He is also a former director
in: Guardian Entertainment Sdn Bhd which specialises in investment
advisory services; Litaran Pasifik Sdn Bhd which is involved in
information, communication and technology products; Konsortium
Multimedia Swasta Sdn Bhd which is involved in several government
internet based services projects; Mass Media Interactive Sdn Bhd which
is involved in investment holding; Oofy Trading Sdn Bhd which is
involved in general merchants and Perfect Academy Sdn Bhd which is a
driving academy.
Kok Han is also a shareholder for companies such
as Titanium Stream Sdn Bhd, Guardian Entertainment Sdn Bhd, Tadika Auza
Sdn Bhd, Cuscapi Bhd and Pusat Latihan Memandu Shah Bandar.
Along with Kok Han, another individual, Mohd Aswadi Mat Zain, seems to be linked with Azam Baki’s brothers and Abu Kassim’s son.
Mohd Aswadi Mat Zain
Aswadi
held 1,000,000 shares in Gets Global Berhad (formally known as KBES
Berhad) as at 31 March 2016. In addition, he was a warrant holder in
Excel Force MSC Berhad. He held 4,082,900 warrants back in March 2016.
These shares and warrants were held during the same period as Azam.
Aswadi
is currently a director of five companies: MEU Technologies Sdn Bhd
which is involved in information technology and software solutions; MSA
Metal Trading Sdn Bhd which is involved in trading in metal and steel;
Uji Niaga Agro Sdn Bhd which is involved in agriculture; Ice Age
Property Sdn Bhd which is involved in trading of Malay property and land
and Premium Hill Marketing Sdn Bhd which is involved in general
merchant.
In addition to being a director, Aswadi is also a
shareholder for some of the above companies. Notably, Aswadi is or was
involved in several companies linked to Abu Kassim’s son, Mohamad Hazmi,
as well as Azam Baki’s brothers, Nasir Baki and Radzuan Baki.
Radzuan Baki
Radzuan
is currently a director of six companies: Premium Hill Marketing Sdn
Bhd which is involved in general merchant, Uji Niaga Agro Sdn Bhd which
is involved in agriculture; Oofy Trading Sdn Bhd which is involved in
general merchants; Ice Age Property Sdn Bhd which is involved in trading
of Malay property and land; MSA Metal Trading Sdn Bhd which is involved
in trading in metal and steel and Veceo Malaysia Sdn Bhd which is now
dormant. Radzuan is also a shareholder for some of these companies.
Together, Azam Baki’s brothers and associates, including Tan Sri Abu Kassim’s son, hold a conglomerate, as shown below: -
Proxies or Associates?
Whilst there is scarce evidence to
accuse Kok Han and Aswadi as Azam Baki’s proxies, there is ample
evidence to conclude that they are his brother’s business associates.
The
conflict of interest becomes inevitable when top law enforcement
officers and/or their family members are involved in a variety of
businesses. It could create opportunities for abuse of power and lead to
corruption.
Hence, should top law enforcement officers be in business?
*Lalitha
Kunaratnam is an investigative journalist and a consultant researcher
for an anti-corruption agency. She is writing in her own capacity, and
the views expressed are not necessarily those of INS*
No comments:
Post a Comment