QUESTIONS arise about the validity of Najib's 2nd Pardon...based on the alleged minutes of the Pardons Board
See Malaysiakini, 18/11/2026 'Declassified: Agong wanted house arrest for Najib despite objections - which also showed the minutes of the Pardon Board Meeting in BM
Now, in my understanding, the KING must act on the advice of the Pardons Board which means that the Pardons Board DECIDES and advices the KING - and KING acts based on the advice of the Pardons Board. It should be a majority decision.
So, in this case, the question is whether the PARDONS Board agreed - because from the 'disclosed minutes' - the AG did not agree, the Minister did not agree, and 2 others also seem to not agree - If the majority in the Pardons Board (AG, Minister, 3 others plus KING) did not agree - it then is IMPOSSIBLE for the King to pardon on the advice of Pardons Board.
Can the KING pardon if the Pardons Board did not agree?
Malaysia is a DEMOCRACY - NOT a FEUDAL STATE. We are a CONSTITUTIONAL MONARCHY where the KING really have LIMITED powers that he can exercise on its own, and PARDON is not one of them > Here the King has to exercise on the advice of the Pardons Board - and the MINUTES do not reflect this. It looks like the KING made the decision irrespective of the objection from AG, Minister Hannah and 2 others..
There was nothing in the MINUTES that the majority of the Pardons Board agreed with the KING
This raises the issue of the VALIDITY of Najib's 2nd Pardon - ordering HOME IMPRISONMENT..
OR did some members AGREE because the KING wanted it > this will be so wrong. Pardon Board members who just agree to whatever King/Ruler wants should be removed - because we need INDEPENDENT Pardon Board members. Did AG, Hannah or the 2 Pardon Board members abandon their objections because the KING wanted it?
The King/Rulers are to act on advice of the Pardons Board > thus the majority decision is what the King can do...because 'act on advice' is defined in the Constitution...
Article 40 Yang di-Pertuan Agong to act on advice
(1) In the exercise of his functions under this Constitution or federal law the Yang di-Pertuan Agong shall act in accordance with the advice of the Cabinet or of a Minister acting under the general authority of the Cabinet, except as otherwise provided by this Constitution; but shall be entitled, at his request, to any information concerning the government of the Federation which is available to the Cabinet.
(1A) In the exercise of his functions under this Constitution or federal law, where the Yang di-Pertuan Agong is to act in accordance with advice, on advice, or after considering advice, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong shall accept and act in accordance with such advice.
The advice of the Pardons Board - is the decision of the majority > and from the minutes, it clearly was not a majority Pardon Board decision that the KING acted on?
**House/Home ARREST is wrong term because in Najib's case, it is continuing to serve his IMPRISONMENT(Prison sentence after conviction) - thus the CORRECT term should be HOME/HOUSE IMPRISONMENT..
It is not an ARREST or even DETENTION - he is serving his sentence of imprisonment after trial...THUS, best to call it HOME/House IMPRISONMENT
See also
Najib's PARDONS - Is it the will of Malaysians to pardon him? A 'political game'? Pardons BOARD decides and KING acts on advice? LAWs to enable Imprisonment at HOME needed - why not enacted fast?
Hannah Yeoh and the ROYAL PARDON - still no Federal Law that will clarify PARDON process, rights and matters related? How Hannah Yeoh and AG decide on Najib's pardon matters???
Pardon reforms needed. The King's pardon - the role of the PM and government of the day? Victim's rights? BERSIH Protest? Prisoner Najib posting on FB?
PARDON powers of King/Rulers is not limitless - Limits are set by Malaysians, through Parliament in laws/Constitution? Lacunae or uncertainty require Constitutional Amendment and/or enactment of a Pardon Law.
Declassified: Agong wanted house arrest for Najib despite objections
Meeting minutes from the Federal Territories Pardons Board hearing where Najib Abdul Razak was granted house arrest have been declassified and confirm that the Yang di-Pertuan Agong assented to granting the former prime minister house arrest despite objections.
Malaysiakini received the minutes from a well-placed source. The portal was also made to understand that the documents were declassified for court purposes, in response to the Bar Council’s legal challenge against the house arrest order.
However, the documents do not appear to have been filed in court as of this morning.
Malaysiakini has contacted Attorney-General Dusuki Mokhtar, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh, the Prime Minister’s Office, the Bar Council and its lawyers, and Najib’s lawyers for comment.
According to the minutes, Dusuki said there was no legal basis for house arrest.
He also said granting house arrest would have major implications for the government in terms of political stability, economic conditions, investments, and the country’s international image.
/file/attachments/orphans/MohdDusukiMokhtar20261006_691083.png)
He stressed that Najib - referred to as the convict (banduan) in the minutes - must serve out their full prison sentence.
Yeoh then said she shared a similar view, reiterating her previous stance on the matter.
Other board members also raised concerns about granting Najib house arrest. Despite this, the king, Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar, ultimately decided to grant house arrest on the condition that RM50 million was paid.
The board then went over a draft of house arrest standard operating procedures, with the Agong making two edits - changing the word “isteri” (wife) to “isteri-isteri” (wives) - regarding those allowed to stay with Najib during house arrest.
The other edit was to remove a clause that would have allowed Najib to host or participate in events if he secured prior written approval from the Prison Department director-general.
Yeoh and Dusuki did not weigh in on the SOPs as they were against the house arrest order.
Minister wanted someone else to sign
Meanwhile, Yeoh, in response to a false pardon decision circulating on social media, suggested in the meeting that another person besides her sign off on the board’s decision, such as the chief secretary to the government.
/file/attachments/orphans/FederalTerritoriesMinisterHannahYeoh191026111_674177.png)
She again cited the major political impact on the government.
However, the Agong pointed out that the chief secretary was not a Pardons Board member and ordered Yeoh to carry out her duties and sign the conditional pardon order.
The full minutes are as follows:...See Malaysiakini, 18/11/2026
AG, Hannah opposed Najib’s house arrest, declassified minutes show
Two other FTPB members also voiced opposition to the house arrest, with one citing Najib Razak's other pending court cases.

According to the minutes, the AG held the view that the former prime minister should complete his reduced sentence in prison, until August 2028.
Dusuki said there were no legal provisions for house arrest under the law, while the move would have implications on political stability, the country’s image at the international level, investments and the economy.
“He stressed that the inmate should continue serving his sentence,” the minutes read, with Yeoh noted as sharing the same views.
Former Federal Court judge Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal, another FTPB member, confirmed that there was no law on house arrest.
However, he said Article 42 of the constitution makes reference to “pardons, reprieves and respites”, and argued that the Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim could exercise his discretion to grant a “respite”.
Fellow FTPB member Razarudin Husain agreed with the views of the AG but said he would defer to the king’s final decision on the matter.
Another board member, Supri Hashim, pointed out that Najib had several other cases pending before the courts, with further jail sentences possible.
Dusuki also said Najib’s bankruptcy proceedings regarding more than RM1.7 billion in tax arrears should be taken into account by the board.
However, the king said the tax arrears should be ignored as they had no relation to the pardon application and Najib had the right to defend his case in court.
The minutes said the Agong then decided to grant the conditional pardon allowing Najib to serve the remainder of his SRC International sentence under house arrest upon payment of his RM50 million fine.
Najib was jailed in August 2022 after the Federal Court upheld his conviction for abuse of power, criminal breach of trust and money laundering involving RM42 million in SRC International funds. He was sentenced to 12 years in jail and fined RM210 million.
In January 2024, the then Agong, Al-Sultan Abdullah Sultan Ahmad Shah, halved Najib’s prison sentence and reduced his fine to RM50 million as part of a royal pardon.
In September this year, the current Agong, Sultan Ibrahim, granted Najib a further conditional pardon, allowing him to serve the remainder of his sentence under house arrest until Aug 23, 2028.
This was subject to Najib paying the RM50 million fine and complying with other stipulated conditions.
The former Pekan MP was placed under house arrest on Nov 10 after Umno helped pay the fine through crowdfunding. - FMT, 18/11/2026
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2026/02/99268a4c548fe91cf548ee0ee89bec89.jpg)

No comments:
Post a Comment