Friday, July 08, 2011

Time for Najib to go - lost even 'influence' over his own party's youth wing

Najib's behaviour and poor handling of the situation involving BERSIH 2.0, the movement for free and fair elections is one thing - but his inability to even get UMNO's youth wing to listen to him is indicative that he has also lost the confidence of even UMNO. Maybe time to call an EGM in UMNO to see whether Najib still enjoys the support of the majority in UMNO?


KUALA LUMPUR: Umno Youth will reapply to gather at Stadium Merdeka but members will gather at Jalan Bukit Bintang at 10am Saturday even if police deny them permission, its chief Khairy Jamaluddin said Friday.

“This afternoon, we will make an application to gather at Stadium Merdeka. We have applied. We were the first to apply for a police permit on June 24. It was rejected on July 6,” the Rembau MP told reporters and showed the appeal letter submitted at the Dang Wangi police station on Friday.

Umno Youth would meet on Jalan Bukit Bintang and might march to the stadium even without permission, he said.

Khairy said Umno Youth was marching on behalf of the “silent majority” who did not agree with Bersih's stand.

Bersih has insisted that it will hold its rally in Stadium Merdeka. - Star, 8/7/2011, Umno Youth to march Saturday to Stadium Merdeka with or without permission

What disturbs me about UMNO Youth is that they are not so much interested in freedom of assembly or expression - but they seem to be interested in a 'clash' with one who hold a different viewpoint. 

First, you should not have decided to have the assembly or rally on the same day and time (and place?). 

Even now, they talk about marching to Stadium Merdeka, the new avenue of the rally. 

And, the claim that they represent the 'silent majority' is absurd...

The 'silent majority' also do have an opinion, and most likely it is similar to those of BERSIH 2.0, i.e. a demand for a more 'free and fair elections in Malaysia' 
The 'silent majority' is "silent" not by reason of choice but by reason of 'coercion, threats, fear, etc' .... do a national referendum on the various points advanced by BERSIH 2.0 where people will freely be allowed to express their choice/vote and I am sure that the majority (if not all) would want a more 'free and fair elections for Malaysia'. Who would say that they do not want it to be more and more free and fair? 

There certainly is always room for improvement, and even the Election Commission has admitted to this - so really, what is the reason for Najib's government's over-reaction to BERSIH 2.0? Why? - maybe, we need to analyze the  'why?' a bit more.  
Faced with mounting pressure that a rally will be held this weekend, the Public Services Department (PSD) has issued a circular barring civil servants from participating in an illegal assembly or any movement which may hurt the security of the nation. - Malaysiakini, 7/7/2011, PSD orders civil servants not to attend rally


However, an Education Ministry circular similarly dated June 30, signed by the director-general Abd Ghafar Mahmud, was more blunt in specifically stating the electoral reform group Coalition of Free and Fair Elections Bersih 2.0. - Malaysiakini, 7/7/2011, PSD orders civil servants not to attend rally
In a note posted on the Universiti Malaya Student Affairs Department Facebook page on June 24, deputy vice-chancellor (student affairs) Rohana Yusof said the university would act against students who take part in the Bersih 2.0 rally.

"Taking part in an illegal assembly is an offence under the University and University Colleges Act 1971 and can lead to suspension or expulsion.

"As such, students are reminded not to be involved in the rally, be it directly or indirectly. If any students are found to be involved, disciplinary action will be taken by the university," she said.- Malaysiakini, 1/7/2011, Gov't anti-Bersih drive hits mosques, campuses

The official campaign against Bersih 2.0 entered the mosques today, with the July 9 rally becoming the topic of Malaysian Islamic Development Department (Jakim)-issued sermons today.

In sermons read out in mosques in Kuala Lumpur before Friday prayers today, the congregations were reminded that the Bersih 2.0 rally is haram (forbidden) as it promoted the wants of individuals at the peril of society.

"Of late, we are worried about a group of extremists who call themselves the Coalition for Free and Fair Elections (Bersih 2.0, which)... is a struggle for the sake of individuals or beliefs, without considering public interests and sensitivities.

"In reaching for their goals, these groups... will converge to cause violence, destruct public amenities and break laws and are willing to go as far as injuring safety personnel," the sermon published on the Jakim website reads. - Malaysiakini, 1/7/2011, Gov't anti-Bersih drive hits mosques, campuses
 Twenty-four hours before the planned rally for clean and fair elections, the government appears to be attempting a last ditch effort to influence Muslims against coming out in droves.

Throughout Kuala Lumpur mosques today, the government-issued sermon called on the congregation to be wary of "those who try to undermine (Muslim) unity".

Unlike last week's sermon, also published on the Malaysian Islamic Development Department (Jakim) website, which mentions Bersih 2.0, the sermon today obliquely warned of "traitors to religion, race and country".

"We would like to state that these people are actually the ones who had caused anger among the Muslims (by) questioning the rights of Muslims as well as using Muslim leaders who have been blinded by their lust for power.

"They incite dissatisfaction and hatred against leaders... behind the mask of fairness and transparency, using the rakyat as human shields when their main agenda is to cause chaos, undermine unity and make us believe that the nation is no longer peaceful," the sermon reads.- Malaysiakini, 8/7/2011,On rally eve, Friday sermon warns of Islam's 'enemies'

Keamanan ala Najib (dan BN) tanpa asas keadilan dan hak asasi bukan apa yang rakyat mahukan

Jika Najib majikan di sebuah syarikat - beliau tidak mahukan pekerja berkesatuan atau bersatu. Beliau tidak akan membenarkan apa-apa aktiviti penyebaran maklumat di antara pekerja. Beliau akan melantik sendiri kroni menjadi wakil pekerja, dan akan hanya berurusan dengan wakil pekerja lantikan beliau - bukan wakil pekerja pilihan semua pekerja kilang. Beliau akan memahukan 'keamanan' - yang bermaksud semua pekerja harus diam-diam kerja sahaja, dan menumpukan perhatian kepada kerja sahaja. Beliau tidak mahu pekerja merunggut - atau meminta apa-apa hak, faedah pekerjaan, perubahan keadaan tempat kerja, ... Terima sahaja apa yang diberikan majikan, dan kerja dengan baik dan aman demi kepentingan kilang (dan keuntungan majikan di mana ini tidak akan dinyatakan tetapi adalah jelas). 

TETAPI, Najib bukan majikan kilang, tetapi Perdana Menteri Malaysia, di mana Malaysia adalah sebuah negara demokratik, bukan sebuah negara di bawah 'diktator' dan bukan negara 'feudal'. Tetapi, malangnya cara Najib dan kerajaan BN mentadbir negara bukan cara bagaimana sebuah negara demokrasi ditadbir.

Keamanan yang dikehendaki Najib bukan 'keamanan" sebenar - tetapi 'keamanan' palsu yang mahukan rakyat diam sahaja, jangan mengritik, jangan mengeluarkan pendapat bercanggahan dengan kerajaan,....terima sahaja apa yang kerajaan memberikan. Ini adalah 'keamanan' sama yang seorang 'diktator' atau kerajaan feudal mahukan. Ini adalah 'keamanan' supaya kedudukan yang memerintah tidak akan dicabar. Ini adalah keamanan yang tidak mendahulukan rakyat - tetapi mereka yang berkuasa dan kroni mereka.

Keamanan sebenarnya mestilah berasaskan keadilan dan hak asasi. Bila terdapat keadilan dan hak asasi rakyat, maka akan adanya keamanan sebenarnya.

Berhenti memperdayakan rakyat dengan mengunakan perkataan "keamanan" apabila



Pergerakan rakyat -lwn- Najib dan kerajaan BN - Najib ada kuasa menyelesaikanny

SUHAKAM: Bersih's made the right move, now gov't's turn

The Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) welcomes the ongoing consultations between the authorities and Bersih relating to the proposed assembly, which will now be held in a stadium, following the advice given by His Majesty Yang Di Pertuan Agong Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin on 4 July and the subsequent audience by Bersih with His Majesty on July 5 2011.

While welcoming this positive development, under the circumstances, the commission wishes to reiterate that freedom of peaceful assembly is provided under Article 10(1)(b) of the federal constitution and article 20(1) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), and that freedom of expression and opinion is provided under Article 19 of the UDHR.

The commission looks forward to the early resolution of the matter between the authorities and Bersih in the spirit of conciliation, as enjoined by His Majesty the Yang Di Pertuan Agong, and shall duly monitor the event.

The commission also wishes to express its concern over the recent arrests and detentions of several members of parliament and activists under Section 3(1) of the Emergency (Public Order and Prevention of Crime) Ordinance 1969 and calls on the authorities to immediately release all those who are still being detained.

They should be accorded their rights to an open trial with legal representation as enshrined in Articles 9, 10 and 11 of the UDHR which state that no one shall be subjected to arbitrary detention; everyone is entitled in full equality to a fair public hearing; and everyone has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.

As a member of the UN Human Rights Council, it is incumbent upon the government to uphold the highest standards in the promotion and protection of the rights of the people. In this regard, the commission has consistently called for repeal of all preventive detention laws and reiterates that detention without trial is a violation of human rights principles.


Hasmy Agam is chairman of Suhakam
 

Thursday, July 07, 2011

Order against 91 should not have been obtained in 'secret' and without those affected given the right to be heard...

I am shocked at the fact that it looks like they went and applied for this order - without even giving a chance for the persons affected to be able to be present before the Magistrate to argue why the order should not be given.
They can "in cases of emergency or in cases where the circumstances do not admit of the serving in due time of notice upon the person against whom the order is made' apply for and get the order ex-parte without the presence of the persons who will be affected by the said order. But surely, in this case, it would have been so easy to inform the persons affected by the order about the said application, and I am sure that they(if not all, at least some) would have rushed to court and argued why the order should not have been given.

Look at the names, and I am sure that the police certainly have their handphones - and an SMS would have been sufficient, and they would have come to court with their lawyers.
Ambiga, for example is a lawyer, and a fax to her law firm would have been so easy to do. I am sure they have all the phone numbers of the others.

And guess what, they made an application for this order yesterday and revealed only late Thursday - just 2 days before the 9/7/2011, and I wonder whether they have even now made any efforts to serve the order and the necessary papers used to make this application. Maybe, they may do it tomorrow - and hence there will be little time to set aside the order. 

When did they make that application? Malaysiakini and Star reports does not tell us much, but the Malaysian Insider report seem to indicate that the made and got the order yesterday - not today. Note also in the updated Malaysiakini report, it seems to suggest that the application was indeed made yesterday - and the order was given yesterday - " The police chief added that the order was approved yesterday..."


KUALA LUMPUR, July 7 — The police obtained a restriction order from the magistrate’s court yesterday under Section 98 of the Criminal Procedure Code to prevent 91 individuals from entering the city. - Malaysian Insider, 7/7/2011,List of individuals barred from KL this Saturday
Malaysiakini report came out 4.44pm, and the Star online report was at 4.54pm - so does this mean, that the fact of the application, the hearing before the Magistrate and even maybe the fact that the order had been obtained (possibly yesterday?) was all intentionally suppressed until late Thurday intentionally to prevent any application to cancel it? 

This is a 'hot issue' and all the mainstream and alternative media agencies would have carried the news almost instantaneously online - was there a conscious suppression of information here? - maybe my friend, Amar Singh, the KL Deputy Police Chief can throw some light on this. And, if the application was made on Wednesday - surely no justification for it to be heard 'ex-parte' without the knowledge or the presence of those who will be affected by this order. They should have been given the right to be heard...

I am shocked also with the Magistrate who allowed himself/herself to be used in this manner - She/He should have just told them to immediately inform the affected parties so that the hearing could have proceeded with all(or some of) the affected parties and their lawyers present. An hour or 2 hours notice would have been sufficient for most (if not all) and their lawyers to make their way to court - as most, I believe are in KL. Anyway, it is about restriction of activity on Saturday, and since the application was made on Wednesday - it was more than reasonable to have postponed the hearing to Thursday and instructed the police (or the government lawyers) to serve or at least give notice to Ambiga and others that the hearing will proceed at this time Thursday..or even Friday. There is no justification for a 'secret' application to get this order.

Unfortunately, we still do not know the name of this Magistrate - let alone the full details of the said order, save for the names of those affected.

Guess what, they have also got the same order against persons currently detained under the Detention Without Trial laws(maybe ISA or the Emergency (Public Order and Prevention of Crime) Ordinance - in their list, I saw the names of Saraswathy and Choo Chon Kai, so is this indication that they will be released today or tomorrow.




Section 98 (Criminal Procedure Code) 
PART IV
PREVENTION OF OFFENCES
CHAPTER X
TEMPORARY ORDERS IN URGENT CASES OF NUISANCE
98.  Power to issue order absolute at once in urgent cases of nuisance.
(1) In cases where in the opinion of a Magistrate immediate prevention or speedy remedy is desirable that Magistrate may, by a written order stating the material facts of the case and served in the manner provided in section 90, direct any person to abstain from a certain act or to take certain order with certain property in his possession or under his management if the Magistrate considers that the direction is likely to prevent or tends to prevent obstruction, annoyance or injury to any persons lawfully employed, or danger to human life, health or safety, or a riot or any affray.

(2) An order under this section may in cases of emergency or in cases where the circumstances do not admit of the serving in due time of notice upon the person against whom the order is made be made ex parte.

(3) An order under this section may be directed to a particular person or to the public generally when frequenting or visiting a particular place.

(4) Any Magistrate may rescind or alter any order made under this section by himself or his predecessor in office.

(5) No order under this section shall remain in force for more than seven days from the making of it.


Malaysiakini Report

Cops: Restriction order against 91 individuals
Regina Lee
Jul 7, 11
4:44pm
The police have placed a restriction order on 91 individuals, including organisers of the Bersih 2.0, Perkasa and Umno Youth's Patriot rallies.

NONEThe order is to stop any of the 91 from being present at several spots in Kuala Lumpur on July 9.

"This means that anyone (on the list) caught present at these areas will be arrested on sight," said the city deputy police chief Amar Singh.

Top on the list are the Bersih 2.0 steering committee members, including Ambiga Sreenevasan, Wong Chin Huat and Maria Chin Abdullah.

Also on the list are Pakatan Rakyat leaders, such as opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, PAS spiritual adviser Nik Aziz Nik Mat, his party's deputy-president Mohamad Sabu, DAP parliamentary leader Lim Kit Siang and social activist Hishamuddin Rais.
Fourteen from Perkasa, including its president Ibrahim Ali and other top leaders such as Ab Rahman Ab Bakar and Syed Hassan Syed Ali.

Umno Youth leaders also included in the list are Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin Abu Bakar, secretary Megat Firdouz Megat Junid and information chief Reezal Merican Naina Merican and eight others.
“This order is to avoid from any activity that can disrupt public order or bring danger to human lives and security.

“With this, they are barred and given warning not to be present or take any part in any assembly in those places on July 9 from 8am to 6pm,” said Amar during a press conference in the Kuala Lumpur police headquarters this evening.

A breach of the order would contravene Section 188 of the Penal Code for disobedience to an order duly promulgated by a public servant, punishable by up to six months' jail or up to RM2,000 fine or both.

The police chief added that the order was approved yesterday and that it has been sent out to the 91 individuals.

Mix-up in list

When asked how the police decided on the 91 individuals, Amar said that it was based on police investigation over the past few weeks.
However, it was evident that although 66 people were listed as Bersih 2.0 supporters, some of them were clearly either Umno members or anti-Bersih.

NONEAmong those on the Bersih 2.0 list are former deputy minister Khalid Yunus, Kulim-Bandar Baharu MP Zulkifli Noordin, Gagasan Melayu Perak president Mohd Hilmi Ismail and national scout chief commissioner Kamaruddin Kachar.

Even Perkasa leaders were listed under Bersih 2.0 supporters such as Negeri Sembilan, Kelantan and Terengganu commissioners Mohd Noor Nordin Abdullah, Sibri Ismail and Mohd Lukman Muda respectively.

The list has also includes at least one mistake. Perkasa vice-president Zubir Harun was listed twice - in the Perkasa and Bersih 2.0 list.

Road closures from Saturday morning

According to the order signed by a Kuala Lumpur Magistrate, the 91 are barred from being along Jalan Syed Putra, Jalan Istana, Jalan Bukit Petaling, Jalan Bellamy and the area surrounding Istana Negara.

They are also barred from Jalan Sultan Hishamuddin, Jalan Lembah Perdana, Jalan Cenderasari and the area around Masjid Negara.

The police also listed Dataran Merdeka, Central Market, Masjid Jamek, Dataran DBKL, Sogo shopping mall, Maju Junction, Kampung Baru mosque, Jalan Kinabalu, Jalan Kuching, Jalan Sultan Ismail, Jalan Haji Taib, Jalan Raja Muda Musa, Jalan Raja Bot, Jalan Dang Wangi, Jalan Munshi Abdullah, Jalan Gereja, Jalan Raja Chulan, Jalan Tun Perak, Jalan Tun Tan Cheng Loke, Jalan Sultan Mahmud as restricted areas to the 91.

Although there were already numerous roadblocks around the country since yesterday, Amar said that the city police will be closing roads and diverting traffic from Friday midnight.

He also said that the police have not received any police permit applications to assemble at press time.- Malaysiakini, 7/7/2011, Cops: Restriction order against 91 individuals

Star Report

Published: Thursday July 7, 2011 MYT 4:54:00 PM
Updated: Thursday July 7, 2011 MYT 5:29:57 PM

91 barred from entering KL business district on July 9

KUALA LUMPUR: The police have obtained a restriction order preventing 91 people, including Bersih organisers, Patriot/Umno Youth and Perkasa from entering the city central business district on Saturday.

Acting city police chief Senior Asst Comm Datuk Amar Sing said the police would enforce the order under Section 98 of the Criminal Procedure Code if any one of the names stated in the order defied the restriction.

Those on the list include Bersih chief Datuk S. Ambiga, Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin and Perkasa president Datuk Ibrahim Ali

"They can be liable and charged under Section 188 of the Penal Code with Disobeying a Lawful Order of the Court which carries a maximum six months imprisonment or a fine or both upon conviction," he said here Thursday. - Star, 7/7/2011, 91 barred from entering KL business district on July 9

Malaysian Insider Report

List of individuals barred from KL this Saturday

July 07, 2011
KUALA LUMPUR, July 7 — The police obtained a restriction order from the magistrate’s court yesterday under Section 98 of the Criminal Procedure Code to prevent 91 individuals from entering the city.
Below are the names:

Perkasa

Dato’ Paduka Ibrahim Ali
Daruk Ab Rahman bin Abu Bakar
Syed Hassan bin Syed Ali
Irawah Fahmi bin Ideris
Roslan bin Kassim
Sharifuddin bin Abd Hamid
Dr Zubir bin Harun
Hj Ameir bin Hj Hassan
Dato’ Ahmad bin Saad
Ahmad Zaini bin Ismail
Muhammad Zaid Md Arip
Abdullah Mansor
Zaira bte Jaafar
Norkhaila binti Jamaludin

Pemuda Umno

Khairy Jamaluddin Abu Bakar
Dato’ Megat Firdouz Tan Sri Megat Junid
Dato’ Seri Reezal Merican Naina Merican
Megat Zulkarnaian Dato’ Omardin
Rizalman Dato’ Mokhtar
Tengku Azman bin Tengku Zainol Abidin
Lokman Noor Adam
Datuk Abdul Azeez bin Rahim
Ungku Saleh bin Ungku Jamal
Arman Azha bin Abu Hanifa
Tun Faisal Ismail bin Aziz

Bersih

Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan
Mohamad bin Sabu
Hishamuddin bin Md Rais
Khairul Anwar bin Ahmad Zainuddin
Maria Chin Abdullah
Chua Tian Chang
Kamarulzaman bin Mohamad
Dr Mohd Hatta bin Md Ramli
Syed Shahir bin Syed Mohamud
Syed Ibrahim bin Syed Noh
Teresa Kok Suh Sim
Badrul Hisham Shaharin
Shamsul Iskandar bin Mohd Akin
Arutchelvam A/L Subramaniam
Wong Chin Huat
Ong Boon Keong
Enalini A/P Elumalai
Haris Fathillah Sathiasingam bin Mohd Ibrahim
Dato’ Khalid Yunus
Dato’ Zulkifli Noordin
Dr Zubir bin Harun
Dato’ Seri Abd Hadi Awang
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim
Lim Kit Siang
Nik Abdul Aziz bin Nik Mat
Nurul Izzah bt Anwar
Kohila A/P Yanasekaran
Zaid bin Kamaruddin
Khoo Teng Swee
Fadiah Nadwa binti Fikri
Yap Swee Seng
Salahuddin Ayub
Dato’ Mahfuz Omar
Nasarudin Hasan
Mazlan Aliman
Dr Syed Azman Syed Nawawi
Dr Dzulkifli Ahmad
Dr Mujahid Yusof
Khalid Abd Samad
Datuk Seri Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin
Azman Shapawi Abd Rani
Suhaizan Kaiat
Nor Azli bin Musa
Mohd Firdaus Jaafar
Loke Siew Fook
Lau Wen San
Mohd Azmin Ali
Mat Shuhaimi Shafie
Satipul Bahari bin Amamt
Wan Hassan bin Mohd Ramli
Mohamad Izzudin Hilmi bin Mohd Zaini
Mohd Shazni Munir bin Mohd Ithnin
Muhammad Hilman bin Idham
Mohd Shukri bin Che Ab Razab
Mohd Syukri bin Kamaruddin
Ahmad Syazwan bin Muhammad Hasan
Choo Chon Kai
Sarasvathy A/P Muthu
Soh Sook Hwa
Nurul Izham bin Nurul Anuar
Abd Rahim bin Osman
Mohd Sibri bin Ismail
Mohd Lukam bin Muda
Datuk Prof Kamaruddin bin Kachar
Dato’ Hj Mohd Noor Nordin bin Abdullah
- Malaysian Insider, 7/7/2011, List of individuals barred from KL this Saturday

PM, honourably allow Malaysians the freedom of assembly and expression - it is still not late to do the right thing

First, they said no street demos -  use Stadiums.... 

The Government is willing to provide a stadium for Bersih 2.0 to hold their rally, said Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak....The Prime Minister said the government would not object if the organiser from the beginning said they would assemble in a stadium from morning to night and later leave peacefully....“Deal nicely and we are willing to prepare a stadium for them to assemble.“But when they refused and instead insisted on having a street demonstration, it must be because of other intentions,” he said....- Star, 4/7/2011, Najib: Government has no objection if July 9 rally in stadium
Then, BERSIH 2.0 went and met with the Yang Di Pertuan Agung, and after that meeting, they called off the street march to the palace, and said that they will gather in the stadium...


Earlier Tuesday, Bersih 2.0 chief Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan emerged after an audience with the King and said the planned street march had been called off.

Instead, the rally would be held in a stadium, she added.- Star, 5/7/2011, PM: Govt to meet Bersih over stadium for rally

Then, Najib positively reacted, and even said that the stadium would be be decided by BERSIH 2.0...and the only condition was that they come, they assemble, they leave peacefully

The Government is prepared to meet with Bersih 2.0 to discuss the movement's plan to organise the July 9 rally in a stadium.Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak said which stadium would depend on the request from the organisers..."We will respond to that accordingly.

"What is important is for them to come to the stadium peacefully and orderly, and leave in the same manner," he told newsmen after chairing Agensi Inovasi Malaysia's first governance council meeting here Tuesday..- Star, 5/7/2011, PM: Govt to meet Bersih over stadium for rally

BERSIH 2.0 chooses Stadium Merdeka - 
Bersih 2.0 has decided to hold its rally at Stadium Merdeka on Saturday, from 2pm to 4pm. - Star, 6/7/2011, Bersih wants to hold rally in Merdeka Stadium on Saturday
And, then Stadium Merdeka said "NO" - these are all government stadiums. 

 The management of Stadium Merdeka has rejected Bersih 2.0's application to use its facilities for the proposed rally on July 9. - Star, 6/7/2011, Stadium Merdeka turns down Bersih application

Then the Minister Rais Yatim said no to the other stadiums in KL....
As Bersih 2.0 is an illegal entity, any application by the rally organiser to use the Merdeka, National and Bukit Jalil stadiums will not be considered, said Information, Communications, Culture and Arts Minister Datuk Seri Rais Yatim. - Star, 7/7/2011, Rais: Rally can’t be held in three KL stadiums

Then there were  other 'new conditions and hurdles' suddenly creeping in.

Then, they said you need to get a police permit...
Police are willing to expedite the permit application by Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (Bersih 2.0) organisers to hold the Saturday gathering in a stadium.

Deputy Inspector-General of Police Datuk Seri Khalid Abu Bakar said it would normally take a week to process such applications but police were willing to expedite the process as this was a “special” case. “The government agreed to allow Bersih to hold its gathering in a stadium, but it must apply for a permit. We will process the application as soon as possible.” - New Straits Times, 7/7/2011, ‘Apply for permit first’

Then, they said that Bersih 2.0 is 'illegal'  - BERSIH 2.0 is a coming together of about 60 civil society groups, with other persons who share this common cause - to demand for a more free and fair elections in Malaysia. Go visit BERSIH website for more information

Another coalition is Gerakan Mansuhkan ISA (GMI), then there was the Save Vui Kong campaign group, and the Justice for Beng Hock campaign, etc - it is absurd that whenever there is a coming together of groups and people for a common cause, there is a need for it to seek registration as a society - and in Malaysia, by the time the registration gets approved, it may take years... 
Now, there are police all 'over' - and temporary bus permits are also not being given - all, I believe, with the intention of preventing people from coming to KL on that day....
Temporary bus permits for travel to Kuala Lumpur will not be issued Friday and Saturday to avoid adding to an anticipated traffic congestion, said the Land Public Transport Commission (SPAD). Its chairman Tan Sri Syed Hamid Albar said Thursday that this applied to school and factory bus operators who often applied for the permits during peak seasons to transport people to the city. - Star, 7/7/2011, No temporary bus permits for Friday and Saturday

Who is creating the problem? I believe it is Najib and the government - it is now such a simple matter with a very easy solution. Allow them to use the Merdeka Stadium - and by 10/7/2011, it will be over. The people coming to KL would also be a boost for the local economy of Kuala Lumpur, transport, accomodation, food, etc...

Well, we shall see what will happen in the next few days - but I appeal to the government to respect human rights and freedoms - including the freedom of peaceful assembly, freedom of speech, expression and opinion, and the freedom for Malaysians to be able to forward their concerns to the Yang Di  Pertuan Agung...

* selected newspaper reports in full below
PUTRAJAYA: The Government is prepared to meet with Bersih 2.0 to discuss the movement's plan to organise the July 9 rally in a stadium.

Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak said which stadium would depend on the request from the organisers.

"We will respond to that accordingly.

"What is important is for them to come to the stadium peacefully and orderly, and leave in the same manner," he told newsmen after chairing Agensi Inovasi Malaysia's first governance council meeting here Tuesday.

Earlier Tuesday, Bersih 2.0 chief Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan emerged after an audience with the King and said the planned street march had been called off.

Instead, the rally would be held in a stadium, she added.- Star, 5/7/2011, PM: Govt to meet Bersih over stadium for rally






PUTRAJAYA: The Government is willing to provide a stadium for Bersih 2.0 to hold their rally, said Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.

The Prime Minister said the government would not object if the organiser from the beginning said they would assemble in a stadium from morning to night and later leave peacefully.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak delivering his speach during the Prime Minister's office monthly gathering at the Dataran Perdana Putera in Putrajaya. Starpic by Mohd Sahar Misni 
 
“Go on, assemble in the stadium and yell and shout till you are drained,

“Do it, its okay. No problem but don't do the street demonstration because it could bring a risk that is very harmful to our country,” he said at the Prime Minister's Department monthly assembly Monday .

Najib said if they were so adamant in submitting a memorandum and the like or even to show dissent in a democracy, they could deal with the authorities.

“Deal nicely and we are willing to prepare a stadium for them to assemble.

“But when they refused and instead insisted on having a street demonstration, it must be because of other intentions,” he said.

He reiterated that street demonstration was not the answer to any issue which could be settled in other ways
Najib said there were parties who were not happy with the election system and claimed that the electoral rolls did not guarantee a free and fair election.
“If that so, how come we lost in five states in 2008 and now the Election Commission is studying the possibility on introducing the biometric system to counter accusation on phantom voters.

“But it is strange that when they won, all quiet and no tales on phantom voters and when they felt that the election is near, this tales will resurface.

“So, the rally is not so much on rectifying the system but the motif is politics...to gain power undemocratically through street demonstration,” he said.

Najib said when a street demonstration takes place, there was no guarantee that it would be a peaceful one.

“Many would join in...those who love rioting and like to create disorder will join in and it will result in a situation which we want to avoid,” he said.

He added that the public should take heed of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin's thoughts on the Bersin 2.0's proposed rally. - Star, 4/7/2011, Najib: Government has no objection if July 9 rally in stadium

Wednesday, July 06, 2011

BERSIH's objective achieved - maybe time to move on to other pressing matters

The Malaysian police is under the Prime Minister and the government, but now one wonders whether the police is more powerful than the Prime Minister - for after the YDP Agung's intervention, there seem to have been an 'agreement' of sorts between the PM who wanted the peaceful assembly not to be done along the roads in Kuala Lumpur but in a stadium. In fact, if I am not wrong, the PM suggested and the BERSIH 2.0 agreed. All that the PM wanted was that it be peaceful - arrive peacefully, assemble/protest peacefully and leave peacefully. But, now the PM seem to be back-tracking (or 'playing out' BERSIH 2.0) and now what he is saying is that the decision rests with the police - and new conditions are being imposed on the organizers - apply for permit, etc

Condition - Apply for Police Permit
In my opinion, it is absurd that the exercise of a right of freedom of assembly and expression is pre-conditioned on an application, and thereafter a permission by the police. If BERSIH applies for police permission, it will be negative implication (a bad precedent) to our struggle for the right and freedom of peaceful assembly. BERSIH can meet, negotiate, discuss, inform, etc - but not seek police permission. This is my own opinion.

Too much power is given to the police. I believe, any person who wants to have a protest or a peaceful assembly should be encouraged to inform the police, who thereafter will be able to do the needful to ensure that the assembly proceeds as plan safely (and peacefully) without the interference of others. Now, police permission is needed when 3 or more want to gather...and this is absurd, and these laws must repealed.

If there are 2 or 3 groups, intending to have a procession and/or assembly, police steps in to make sure that the events are happening at different venues and/or there is no clash of the routes of these procession. This is what happens at every nomination day of the General Elections, and what is wonderful in Malaysia is that these assemblies/processions are always relatively peaceful - no clashes/fights/bloodshed/etc . This is the Malaysian way - and it can be done. 

What do the members of the different opposing groups do even when they are near each other - there will be hurling of slogans(words) at each other, etc - quite entertaining really... but no violence or physical fights.

"Violence" and chaos usually erupts when the police attempts to disperse peaceful assemblies, using truncheons, water cannons, tear gas, etc...and party being violent is normally the police not the protesters.

The cause of the 'violence', chaos ...always starts with the police generally. This has been my observation.

HRH the King and our Prime Minister have given the 'green light', and the police should have no role whatsoever deciding whether permission be given or not, imposing conditions,etc. What the PM wants simply is that the event be peaceful and not violent - that is all. Now, BERSIH says they want the gathering at Merdeka Stadium - and what PM (as head of government and 'boss' of police) should do is say "OK" - and tell them to make sure all goes on peacefully. And that is that...

I expected today that all being detained in connection with BERSIH 2.0 will be released, and all charges pending in court will be withdrawn. I expected such an announcement from our PM - still waiting for it.

I went to KL today, and before the Bentong Toll - there were about 30 police officers and some busses were pulled aside. Why? 

WHY? WHY? WHY? The matter has already been resolved. 

The free and fair election movement has compromised a lot (too much, in my opinion) - they have agreed to no more walk to the palace to hand over the peoples' memorandum on the issue to the YDP Agung - now, it will just be a gathering at a Stadium. 

The public advocacy and awareness building element that would have happened in a procession/peaceful assembly at the road side, etc within the sight and hearing of other Malaysians will also no longer be there in a Stadium ( a closed environment) where the other Malaysians will not be able to see or hear - as there is also likely to be no live direct telecast on TV or radio, or  agreements that allow the placement of large screens in places where other members of the public can see and hear what is happening in the Stadium. 

Really, if it is going to be held in a Stadium, maybe best for the organizers to consider just cancelling the event. It makes no sense to have a gathering of the 'converted' sitting and listening to talks/speeches/slogans that they already agree to.

BERSIH 2.0's objective achieved already
In fact, one can say that the objectives of BERSIH 2.0, that movement for free and fair elections have already been achieved..

* Thanks also to the poor reactions by the government and the police, the awareness of the failings of current election commission and election process, and the proposed 'changes' needed to make it more free and fair is already there. People are already talking and still talking about this - and even our Election Commission has reacted, sadly with apologetics and defending what is present as being fair and free. A good independent Election Commission will and should always accept, consider and implement any suggestions from any Ali, Devi, Mary or Chan for always the election process and system can be made MORE and MORE fair and free.


* The other objective was to convey the views of the Malaysian people to the Yang Di Pertuan Agung. Well, if there was a delegation or a procession, that memorandum would most likely be received by some officer or person for and on behalf the Yang Di Pertuan Agung. Now, the Chairperson and 2 others from BERSIH 2.0 was granted a private audience with the King. This was an achievement so far greater, I believe, that what the organizers and the people of this movement would have dreamt off.

So, is there really any more reason to pursue a gathering in a 'room' away from the eyes and ears of the other Malaysians?

So, is there any more reason to subject oneself to actions, omissions, failings, 'conditions', etc of our Prime Minister (and his police)

Maybe, it is time to move on to other issues and concerns in Malaysia...like the current threat to employment relationships in Malaysia...

Our Malaysian government is trying yet again to destroy the nature of employment relationship in Malaysia, that has been in existence since independence to something that will be most detrimental to all current and future workers in Malaysia.

I will explain:-

NOW - in a factory, plantation or workplace, owned and/or operated by the principal, there is ONE employer (the principal) and all the workers at the workplace are the employees of this ONE employer. If there are complaints, disputes and issues, then the workers will deal with their employer. If there is a union, then all workers of the ONE employer can be members. If there is to be a collective agreement, then the union or the workers collectively can sit down and work out with this ONE employer (the principal).

What the Malaysian government is trying to do is to change this current employment relationship - and create a situation whereby in a factory, plantation or workplace, not all the workers there will be employees of the ONE employer (the principal). There will be workers (or groups of workers) who will be employees of OTHER Employers - not the principal, and as such these workers no longer will be treated the same as all other workers, no longer will they be able to join unions or collectively negotiate(or bargain) with the ONE employer (the principal) because they will be no longer employees of the principal but some other.

Who are these OTHER employers? They will be the 'contractors for labour', and today this would include those now known as 'outsourcing agents/companies'. In the 2010 Bill that wanted to amend the Employment Act, that Bill clearly stated that the definition of employer will be extended to suppliers of workers/labour - but in the new amendment, this was left out, but the other sections proposed achieve the same meaning and end result, and if passed these suppliers of workers, the 'contractors for labour', will be and will continue to remain the employers of workers that they supplied to principals  to work at the factories, plantations and workplace of the principal.

This situation where there are groups of workers of 'other employers' at a factory, plantation or workplace would certainly weaken workers, their unions and their strength in the collective bargaining process to improve their working condition, wages, benefits, etc... That ONE Employer(Principal) can simply ignore the demands - and of course, if they still demand, so easily can he just start using more and more workers from the 'OTHER' employers, to whom the Principal will have no legal duties as employer, and no need to worry about their rights, welfare or other work benefits.

We have to create awareness about what our pro-business pro-employer government is trying to do, and stop them from legalizing this and destroying what is now a more just employment relationship, that will protect worker rights and welfare. 

The Employment (Amendment) Bill 2011 was tabled on 21/6/2011 - and may be passed speedily at the next sitting of the Dewan Rakyat, if we, who are concerned about justice and human rights, do not now do something about this...

ONE factory/plantation/workplace ONE employer(the principal), and ALL workers working there will be employees of that ONE employer (the principal).

For more about this, see my earlier posts:-

Beware the new Employment(Amendment) Bill 2011 detrimental to all workers and unions

Will our MPs protect workers and unions? The proposed Bill to amend employment act..

Employment (Amendment) Bill 2011 must be opposed for the sake of Malaysian workers and unions

STOP government attempt to legalize outsourcing agents and their 'illegal' practices

Parasites of workers’ sweat and toil

Malaysian workers will get payment for overtime only the following month - WHY?

There are, of course, other issues of concern that needs addressing... but, I have just raised one, which I consider needs a lot of public awareness and campaigning. 

Remember, Bills in Parliament passes through easily for MPs vote not according to their conscience or principles BUT what the BN bosses tell them... so without a serious campaign and opposition of Malaysians - it will pass, and great injustice will be caused to the over 10 million workers (and their families) and all future workers in Malaysia.


Tuesday, July 05, 2011

Immediately release all arrested & withdraw charges in connection with the movement for free and fair elections

And now, as a show of good faith, the Prime Minister Najib and the BN government must immediately release all those arrested and detained in connection with BERSIH 2.0, the movement for free and fair elections.

Will the charges all be dropped? Will those being detained under Detention Without Trial laws be immediately and unconditionally released?
The government must do this by reason of what has happened after the meeting with the Yang Di Pertuan Agung, and also following the government's offer to allow the BERSIH 2.0 rally to proceed in a Stadium, which was accepted by BERSIH.

The Home Minister's declaration that BERSIH 2.0 is unlawful seems absurd now, and must be immediately revoked.
Note also that it is our Prime Minister, that made the proposal to BERSIH 2.0, and they have accepted it, i.e. to have the rally at a Stadium. It is absurd to still say that the coalition is 'unlawful' and the T-shirts and other campaign material is still 'subversive'.

In my opinion, the continued detention and charges in court will be contrary to very intention of the Yang Di Pertuan Agung, our Prime Minister Najib Razak and the government. All materials seized must also be returned now - possibly to be used in the peaceful assembly at the Stadium.

To be fair, PERKASA must also be given a different Stadium venue for their peaceful rally to express their views and opinions on free and fair elections.

To be fair, similar provisions must also be given to the UMNO Youth for their event.

Surely, both PERKASA and UMNO Youth should also receive equal treatment and accorded the opportunity to express themselves on the issue of free and fair elections. If they now decide, that they do not want to do so in a closed Stadium, then their very intention for wanting also to have a 'peaceful assembly' at the same time becomes a question. 

Many will now say that all they wanted was to just prevent the exercise of BERSIH 2.0's right to a peaceful assembly and freedom of expression/speech. 

PERKASA and UMNO Youth must also proceed and have their own events, and prove me wrong - showing that they had something to say about the issue of free and fair elections, and was not merely interested in disrupting the BERSIH event. 

We will all also look at the number of persons that attend the PERKASA and the UMNO Youth event to access whether they really do have the support of ordinary Malaysians - or whether it was just a small number. Or maybe, they will not have the event because they really do not have much support.
A peaceful assembly in a Stadium would surely attract a much smaller number - because for many it would have been to lobby for more support from other ordinary Malaysians - who are sitting on the fence now. In a stadium, this audience will not be there & it may be more just people of the same stand coming together. 

Will the event be covered by RTM, TV, Radio and mainstream media so that the points expressed can and will be communicated to all Malaysians for their consideration - and maybe ultimately their decision, i.e. to support all, to support some, to reject all, to reject some or to still remain indifferent and take no position.

The government has declared a truce with the Coalition for Free and Fair Elections (Bersih 2.0), agreeing to allow its rally to be held in a stadium.

"I understand Bersih wants to have a meeting with the government on having the rally in a stadium (and) we are ready to meet them," Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak said today.

However, he said the organisers must agree to several conditions.

"(They must) go peacefully, assemble peacefully and leave peacefully," said Najib.


Earlier today,three members of Bersih 2.0 were granted an audience by the Agong, during which they agreed to hold the rally in a stadium as a compromise to the original idea of a street rally.

However, no details of the venue and date were immediately available. - Malaysiakini, 5/7/2011, PM gives nod to rally in stadium

Bail set at RM8,000 is excessive and unjust - and should never be used as a 'deterrent'

Noting the more that 30% of Malaysian workers, according to the government, earn RM700 or less as monthly wages, that is lower than the poverty rate of RM720.

Remember also that a person is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Bail is merely to ensure that one who has been charged attends court on their trial dates. 

There really is no need to even set any bail amount if a person charged will attend court - and, if they have a known home where he/she have been residing for a long time, have a job/works in the area, is not likely to abscond, bail could be zero or very nominal.Would they run away and not be there for their trial dates? Even so, there is always the possibility of issuing an arrest warrant if a person does not turn up for trial.

But RM8,000 per person is just too excessive. That is almost equivalent to about 1 years salary for many workers in Malaysia. This, I believe, it may be seen as being  'punitive' in nature and this should not be. 

In 1998 also, following the REFORMASI peaceful assembly many were arrested, and even remanded for several days - and then charged and imposed a much lower but high bail, and one of the reasons for extended remand and/or high bail was 'deterrence' (according to the submissions of some of the government lawyers when submissions were being made, and for the record, I was there representing the said suspects/accused)   - i.e. to scare other people into stopping exercising their right to peaceful assembly. Remanding persons for longer than necessary or imposing of high bails as means of deterring others is so wrong. 

The purpose of further remand is that time is required to complete the police investigation concerning allegations levied against the suspect - and, in the case where persons are caught participating in an 'illegal assembly' - handing out 'subversive materials', there really is no justification keeping them for more than 24 hours - unless the Malaysian police is highly inefficient. There is nothing much to investigate for these kind of offences that requires the suspects continued presence in detention, is there?

The purpose of bail is simply to secure the attendance of the accused on his/her trial or court dates - not ever to be used as a 'deterrence' to stop others from doing something, or even as a deterrent to prevent the particular accused person from repeating his actions that led to his/her being charged in court. 

So, why was it RM8,000 for bail? Independent courts and judiciary should always be seen as being independent - and that means not being seen as siding the existing government or others. Was the imposition of RM8,000 as bail done for some other reason other than just for ensuring attendance of the accused in court?

Unlike police bail, which involves no actual payment of money then and there - only a commitment of liability to a certain sum if the suspect does not turn up at the appointed date and time, court bail is very different. It requires the actual payment of the 'bail amount', and the surety will have no access to this money until after the trial. [RM8,000 X 24 = RM192,000, and this iis money sufficient to buy 4 - 5 low cost houses, Even a State Assembly Person's salary is about RM4,000]

Justly and reasonably, bail amounts should be nominal, if at all. For Malaysians, having a permanent address, employment, etc in a locality for some time, there really is no need for any bail amount. If they do not turn up in court, on the appointed date, then it is a different matter. Even, if bail is to be fixed, it should certainly be not more than RM500, and the personal income of the person need to be considered. For a worker, earning RM700, as a rule of thumb bail should not exceed 30% of the income. Of course for a CEO earning RM500,000-00 or a rich person, this amount could be higher. Court bail should also maybe be like police bail - where the surety commits to paying the sum of RM___ if the accused absconds or do not turn up in court for trial - no need for actual deposit of money in court.

The 24 PSM activist was involved in the movement for a free and fair elections in Malaysia - and allegedly were distributing flyers about the possible July 9 peaceful gatherings. Is there anything subversive about this? I do not think so.

KUALA LUMPUR, July 2 — Electoral reforms movement Bersih 2.0 has been declared illegal by the Home Ministry effective July 1 for causing “an atmosphere of unrest,” a week before its planned July 9 rally. _ Malaysian Insider, 2/7/2011, Hisham outlaws Bersih 2.0

Note, that they were charged for something that happened on 25/6/2011 - when our Home Minister only declared Bersih 2.0 illegal effective 1/7/2011.
They were alleged to have committed the act (of being involved in an illegal assembly dubbed Bersih 2.0) at 3.30pm on June 25 at the Sungai Dua Toll Plaza, along the North-South Expressway in Seberang Perai Utara. - Malaysiakini, 4/7/2011, Unlawful group: PSM activists charged
What is also disturbing is the fact that all this charging, etc is happening after the statement of the Yang Di Pertuan Agung?

Twenty-four Parti Sosialis Malaysia (PSM) activists were jointly charged today under Section 48(1) of the Societies Act 1966, in connection with the Bersih 2.0 rally scheduled for July 9.

The 24 face an alternate charge under Section 43 of the same Act. The group pleaded not guilty to the charge and bail for each was set at RM8,000.

NONEThey were alleged to have committed the act (of being involved in an illegal assembly dubbed Bersih 2.0) at 3.30pm on June 25 at the Sungai Dua Toll Plaza, along the North-South Expressway in Seberang Perai Utara.

Judge Ikmal Hisham Mohd Tajuddin fixed July 21 as the mention date. The 24 include two minors and a woman in her 60s.

Section 48 of the Act states that anyone who acts on behalf of or represents an unlawful society by bringing with them 600 photocopies of pamphlets is liable to a maximum penalty of five years' jail, a fine of up to RM5,000, or both.

Section 43 of the Act stipulates that whoever is a member, attends meetings of or aids an unlawful society is liable, on conviction, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years or to a fine not exceeding RM5,000 or both.

The group is also jointly charged under Section 29 (1) of the Internal Security Act for being in possession of subversive documents.

If convicted, the punishment includes a fine of less then RM10,000, a jail term of less than five years or both.

Bail on each of the charges was set at RM4,000.

Bid to reduce bail amount

The PSM lawyers tried to reduce the amount of bail set as the group comprised “poor people who are farmers, estate workers, students and unemployed”.

They also said that several detainees had health problems, including diabetes and high blood pressure, and could not afford such an expensive bail.

Deputy public prosecutor Suhaimi Ibrahim argued that the amount of bail was necessary to ensure that the accused would be present at the hearing.

The PSM activists, who have been remanded by police since June 26, were taken to the court in Butterworth at 1.40pm today.

Family members, who had been waiting outside the court building since 8am, shouted “Hidup Rakyat!” (Long live the people) when the Black Maria arrived with the activists inside.

psm arrest penang case court 040711The group comprises those still under detention after 59 PSM leaders and members were detained on July 25.

PSM secretary-general S Arutchelvan (left) said the entire episode of making the lawyers and families wait was “sheer cowardice”.

The PSM supporters had been told the detainees would be charged or released at 8am, 11am, 1pm and then at 3pm.

However, until 4pm, the lawyers were still waiting for the charge sheet.

Arutchelvan expressed concern that the banks would not be open to process bail if the charges were made at such a late hour.

“This is an act of bullying. Since we've been here, the police have been telling us that they are waiting for orders from Putrajaya,” he said.

“Clearly, this has nothing to do with the law.”

Meanwhile, Deputy CID chief Mohd Nasir Salleh informed the supporters and families that he was waiting for the DPP to arrive from Balik Pulau.

There was reportedly a massive traffic jam, he said, and told everyone to be patient. - Malaysiakini, 4/7/2011, Unlawful group: PSM activists charged

Sunday, July 03, 2011

MCCBCHST : Peaceful assembly our constitutional right

The Malaysian Consultative Council of Buddhism Christianity, Hinduism, Sikhism and Taoism (MCCBCHST) notes that Bersih Organisers, Perkasa and Umno Youth are intending to hold peaceful assemblies on 9 July 2011.

MCCBCHST is of the view that since our federal constitution, the supreme law of our land provides under Article 10(1Xb) that "all citizens have the right to assemble peaceably and without arms", the proposed assemblies by the said groups should be allowed.

Further, one of the pillars of our Rukun Negara is "Keluhuran Perlembagaan". i.e. Supremacy of the Constitution.

Even the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) has stated that the people have the constitutional right to assemble peaceably and the government should allow it. 

Any pre-emptive banning of proposed peaceful assemblies would mean that one has no right to peaceful assembly, making the fundamental guarantee illusory.

The police have the duty and the capacity to control such assemblies and can designate routes and separate the different groups as has been done during the recent by-elections.

The fact that such assemblies may cause traffic jams and inconvenience the people is not a legitimate reason.
People generally are prepared to put up with some inconveniences in furtherance of their fundamental rights.
Many national and religious functions and processions are held on regular basis and Malaysians have accepted these inconveniences as part and parcel of the heritage of our Malaysian Society.

MCCBCHST therefore appeal to the police to act professionally in the matter and allow people to exercise their fundamental right to peaceful assembly.

The police can call the groups concerned and make arrangements on the route each may take. On the day itself police should be there to separate the groups and to control the traffic.

The MCCBCHST calls upon all concerned citizens of Malaysia to earnestly pray that all parties concerned will conduct themselves with decorum and respect, as we approach the day of the proposed peaceful assembly._ Malaysiakini, 30/6/2011, Peaceful assembly our constitutional right