HAZE - Can Malaysia prosecute criminally liable in Malaysia? YES, (in my opinion) they can for this CRIME as it is an offence in MALAYSIA the moment the haze enters Malaysia's jurisdiction. It is not like MURDER or other crimes where it happens in other countries... FULL STOP.
Malaysia's COURTS have jurisdiction the moment the HAZE enters Malaysia's jurisdiction...in my opinion, it matters not where the source of the pollution is ...the burning/fires could be in Indonesia, ...or even INDIA(it matters not) - but the moment it becomes pollution in Malaysia affecting Malaysians, it becomes a CRIME ... and thus the perpetrator/s can be charged and tried in Malaysia for a Sec. 22 crime...???
Sec. 22 Restrictions on pollution of the atmosphere [ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT 1974]
(1) No person shall, unless licensed, emit or discharge any environmentally hazardous substances, pollutants or wastes into the atmosphere in contravention of the acceptable conditions specified under section 21....
...(3) Any person who contravenes subsection (1) commits an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine of not less than ten thousand ringgit and not exceeding one million ringgit or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or to both, and shall also be liable to a further fine not exceeding one thousand ringgit for every day during which the offence continues after a notice by the Director General requiring him to cease the act specified therein has been served on him.
But, is emitting or causing haze, smoke, etc a CRIME - because then, we have look at what is permissible and what is NOT - when will HAZE or smoke a crime? Do we have those standards - Malaysia should have it since HAZE has been a problem for some time > OR has Malaysia failed to set up LIMITS - when it becomes a CRIME.
Same too, with SOUND - when it exceeds a certain LIMIT, it becomes a CRIME> also when it contravenes acceptable standards/conditions set by the government > a little HAZE/Smoke may not be a crime until it is OVER a certain limit set by government.
In my opinion, if the HAZE is above a certain dangerous value, it automatically becomes a CRIME irrespective where the SOURCE of the Haze is....so, it should be actionable as a CRIME.
Better if Malaysia also has a Transboundary Haze Pollution Act 2014, as what Singapore has > thus the failure of Government and/or Parliament to enact such an ACT for Malaysia yet...
BUT, even without such a Trans boundary Haze Pollution Act 2014, I believe that it is still a CRIME under the ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT 1974 and possibly other existing laws.
Then, there are the CIVIL Remedies - where action can be taken in Malaysia, and even in the COUNTRY where the persons/entity are or the source of the pollution exist.
The one QUESTION has been whether the causers of this HAZE are also Malaysioans?
There is no conclusive evidence that Malaysian-linked plantation companies were responsible for fires in Indonesia, Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability (NRES) Minister Datuk Seri Arthur Joseph Kurup said. He said NRES and the Plantation and Commodities Ministry had examined allegations that Malaysian companies were involved in burning activities in Indonesia. “Based on our assessment to date, there is no conclusive evidence confirming that Malaysian-linked plantation companies were responsible for the fires. “The government’s position is clear that any party proven to be responsible for haze pollution must face appropriate action in accordance with the law,” he said. - Malay Mail, 28/10/2026
However, what the Minister says contradicts what Indonesian groups are saying - and what Singapore has done?????
Indonesian environmental non-governmental organisation Wahana Lingkungan Hidup Indonesia (WALHI) has claimed that 21 companies linked to business groups with Malaysian ties were involved in forest and land fires in Indonesia between January and September 2026. - NST, 26/10/2026
Four companies with links to Malaysian-listed groups have been caught up in Singapore's efforts to tackle the haze that has lingered across the region for weeks....Two are Singapore-incorporated subsidiaries of Bursa Malaysia-listed TSH Resources Bhd – TSH Global Plantation Pte Ltd and TSH Oversea Pte Ltd.The third is Wilmar International Ltd, a Singapore-listed agribusiness group in which Malaysia's PPB Group Bhd holds about 18.8 per cent.The fourth, Kencana Agri Ltd, has a more indirect connection. Wilmar holds a 20 per cent stake in the company through a subsidiary. - NST, 27/10/2026
Has HAZE caused death, injury or sickness > then, it is also another criminal offence amd action can be taken?
MINISTER - tell us how many have suffered medically because of HAZE > No one - is it NOT a HEALTH RISK?
MINISTER - tell us if HAZE is above the permitted limits? Have you investigated to determine conclusively the SOURCE --- because the Government naturally has the resources to do this? What are the findings?
There is also the POSSIBILITY of the Malaysian Government to commence Court Actions in INDONESIA itself, now that the Haze is affecting Malaysians and even disrupting our enjoyment to life??
Follow the Charles Hector channel on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029Vb6UokfB4hdNugYmph1B
Who’s behind the haze? No conclusive evidence linking Malaysian firms to Indonesia fires, says Arthur Kurup
KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 28 — There is no conclusive evidence that Malaysian-linked plantation companies were responsible for fires in Indonesia, Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability (NRES) Minister Datuk Seri Arthur Joseph Kurup said.
He said NRES and the Plantation and Commodities Ministry had examined allegations that Malaysian companies were involved in burning activities in Indonesia.
“Based on our assessment to date, there is no conclusive evidence confirming that Malaysian-linked plantation companies were responsible for the fires.
“The government’s position is clear that any party proven to be responsible for haze pollution must face appropriate action in accordance with the law,” he said.
Arthur was winding up the debate on the Supply Bill 2027 for his ministry in the Dewan Rakyat today. He was responding to Mohamad Shafizan Kepli (GPS-Batang Lupar), who asked about proposals for specific legislation to address transboundary haze pollution and action against companies found responsible.
Arthur said the proposal to restrict financing for companies proven to be responsible for haze pollution required further scrutiny, particularly regarding the legal basis, evidentiary standards, jurisdiction and implications for the financial sector.
“The ministry has also examined on several occasions the merits of enacting a Transboundary Haze Pollution Act, similar to legislation introduced by a neighbouring country.
“However, implementation would present challenges, particularly in terms of jurisdiction, the collection and verification of evidence overseas, the determination of corporate liability and the implications for the sovereignty of other countries,” he said.
On proposals to seek compensation and damages, Arthur said the Asean Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution (AATHP) did not currently provide a specific mechanism for compensation claims between countries.
“Nevertheless, the government is open to examining the suitability of other legal mechanisms, subject to the availability of a basis under international law.
“A comprehensive study of the economic losses caused by haze, including its effects on public health, productivity and economic activity, is important in providing a scientific and economic basis for policy considerations and follow-up action,” he said. — Bernama- Malay Mail, 28/10/2026


No comments:
Post a Comment